Home | Comment & Analysis    Tuesday 11 February 2014

Malnutrition data for Darfur still Being withheld

separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation

By Eric Reeves

February 10, 2014 - For several years now, one of the great deficiencies in our understanding of and response to the humanitarian crisis in Darfur has been a lack of data relevant to assessments of malnutrition, hygiene, primary medical care, access to clean water, and education. A UNICEF report of January 29, 2014 suggested a breakthrough on this score:

For the first time in Sudan, the Simple Spatial Survey Methodology (S3M) has been used to collect data on child malnutrition, showing the difference in performance of health and nutrition services right down to locality level; in each of Sudan’s 18 states. "The S3M survey is a gold mine of credible data on child malnutrition and its underlying causes. Up-to-date, reliable data are indispensable to realize the right of every child in Sudan. They are essential to plan, budget, refine and deliver services for children in every locality of the country," said Mr Geert Cappelaere, UNICEF’s Representative in Sudan. "Up to now, Sudan has only had general data on the nutritional status of its children, and we know that national and even state level averages often mask disparities at lower levels. With these new survey results, we know exactly where the pockets of high need are located. This means that investment can be tailored to make sure that every single child in need is reached."

Readers of the report were informed that for more information—presumably about the specific findings of the S3M report—they should contact UNICEF:

Lone Hvass, UNICEF Khartoum, lhvass@unicef.org
Mara Nyawo, UNICEF Khartoum, mnyawo@unicef.org

The reply to my February 1, 2014 request for such information came today (February 10, 2014) in the form of a terse, all too predictable email:

Dear Mr Reeves
Thank you for your interest in the survey.
The results are with the Federal Ministry of Health and are not with UNICEF to distribute, we can however put you in touch with the relevant person in the Ministry of Health if that would be helpful.
Best regards
Mara Nyawo
Nutrition Specialist (Surveillance)

But of course it is the Ministry of Health and the perversely named Humanitarian Aid Commission (HAC) that have been responsible for the suppression of data for a number of years, have refused to allowed completed reports and analyses be promulgated publicly, and has generally done all it can to obscure humanitarian realities in Darfur. Both regime organs have also been responsible for or complicit in the obstruction of humanitarian relief operations and delivery of supplies into Darfur. The notion that they would offer anything to an inquiring American who has been critical of Khartoum’s actions in Darfur for over a decade is of course preposterous—and known by Ms. Nyawo to be so.

Fortunately for those interested in the realities of Darfur at present, Geert Cappelaere, UNICEF’s Representative in Sudan, spoke subsequently at a press conference, although this was reported only by Radio Dabanga (Khartoum, February 5, 2014):

Half of the children in Darfur are out of school, and 40 percent of them suffer from chronic malnutrition, the Representative of the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF) in Sudan revealed on Monday [February 3]. UNICEF Representative Geert Cappelaere on Monday briefed the press about the conclusions of a study carried by UN agencies in Sudan. He stated that minors constitute 65 percent of the population in Darfur. Most of them are living in camps for the displaced. A total of 1.2 million children in Sudan’s western region do not have access to basic services. Half of the Darfuri children are out of school, and 40 percent of them suffer from chronic malnutrition. Only six women out of 100 give birth in health centres. 300 out of 100,000 women die in childbirth.

These are extraordinary and terrifying findings, and nothing in the report released by UNICEF suggests just how frightening these figures should be. Notably, this account by Cappelaere does not indicate whether the "chronic malnutrition" that afflicts 40 percent of Darfuri children is Global Acute Malnutrition (GAM), for which the "critical emergency" threshold is 15 percent (see "Glossary: Global Acute Malnutrition (GAM)," Complex Emergency Database) or Global Chronic Malnutrition (GCM), commonly known as "stunting." Context and information from sources on the ground strongly suggest that it is the latter, but that leaves us with a critical question: what is the Global Acute Malnutrition rate for Darfur? It has, in various locations at various times, been reported as well over the 15 percent "critical emergency" threshold: what is the situation now? Why is this figure not part of the report? or Mr. Cappelaere’s otherwise revealing news conference? A number of ominous possibilities suggest themselves.

[The UN OCHA report of January 27 – February 2, 2014 was no more revealing on this critical question.]

For context, for an understanding of Khartoum’s attitudes towards humanitarian assessments and efforts in Darfur, we should recall the regime’s February 1, 2014 suspension of the International Committee of the Red Cross from all humanitarian activities in Darfur. Reliable sources indicate that what was initially glossed over as a bureaucratic issue was in fact much more ominous: the Khartoum regime, desperately cash-strapped, had demanded of the ICRC that it deliver a substantial portion of its own operating funds to the Sudanese Red Crescent, a demand that the ICRC rightly refused. Although it has been suggested that the SRC had itself demanded substantially more direct funding from the Geneva-based ICRC—and that this was what Khartoum meant by declaring the ICRC was "working outside its mandate"—no such high-profile incident as we have seen unfold could have been provoked without regime authorization. And nothing could better capture Khartoum’s contempt for the integrity of humanitarian operations or the desperate plight of the people of Darfur.

The heading given to the January 29, 2014 official UNICEF release of its report was, "Sudan launches new data on child malnutrition; UNICEF calls for all-out effort to support the fight against malnutrition in Sudan." But as long as UNICEF refuses to provide access to these data, as long as it remains fully under the control of the Khartoum regime, then we know that no watershed for the disclosure of humanitarian data has been reached, at least for Darfur. And as long as we don’t know the critically revealing Global Acute Malnutrition rate for Darfur, we are in danger of misunderstanding the nature of a vast and accelerating emergency.

Why won’t these data be released?

Eric Reeves is professor of English Language and Literature at Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts, who has written extensively on Sudan and South Sudan. He can be reached at ereeves@smith.edu.



The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it to comment@sudantribune.com

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication. Please include your full name, relevant personal information and political affiliations.
Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 12 February 11:41, by Darkangel

    Sudantribune insist on publishing every crap that comes out of this demented mans mouth.
    How about some professional articles for a change Sudantribune - here ill give you a hand !
    ****** MUST READ ******
    BEST ANALYSIS OF SOUTH SUDAN CONFLICT
    South Sudan: No Power-Sharing Without Reform
    http://www.newvision.co.ug/news/652467-south-sudan-no-power-sharing-without-reform.html

    repondre message

  • 15 February 14:47, by Mohammed Ali 2

    Prof.Doom is making fuss out of nothing ! The survey is made by the ministry of health and it is not a secret.The minister of health is Abu gerda who is until recently was a Darfurian rebel!He joined the government about 2 years after Doha agreement.The survey in Daefur is held by Darfurians doctors & health administors.It has nothing to do with the humanterian comission.

    repondre message

    • 15 February 15:02, by Mohammed Ali 2

      The data which you UN release about west Sudan " not Darfur only" could be true of most rural areas in Sudan.It is not a secret.We are not happy with it.If you leave us alone and stop war-mongering we could improve much better than this.

      repondre message

      • 15 February 15:22, by Mohammed Ali 2

        Prof.Doom is diverting attention away from the plight of SS , which he has a big role in creating.As part of the "Faild State" lobby who coddled and absolved the SPLA from any responsibility, even when they loooooted $ 12 Billions in 6 years only.The blame always falls on the Arab north, NCP,ISLAM ..,bla...blaa.Prof.Doom has certainly got his fair share from this flow of non-sensered money.

        repondre message

        • 15 February 15:29, by Mohammed Ali 2

          The UN food program says that there are 7 millions out of 8 millions in South Sudan are starving.Tens of southands had already died and I can assure you that more than 100,000 already died in this 2 months only conflict.From the first week the UN said "tens of thousands" perised.They killing is at random and continuing.The SPLA has disintegrated.

          repondre message

          • 15 February 15:41, by Mohammed Ali 2

            Prof Doom & the like from the "faild state" lobby want to supress this data.The world is small & there so many honest people who will tell the truth to the world.If the "faild state" lobby continue absolving the SPLA thieves from their grave responsibilities the war in S.S will continue to a devastating unprecedented end.So many innocent pple will die unnecessarily.The blame will not fall upon us!

            repondre message

Comment on this article


 
 

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.


Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis


2015 elections are not a priority for Sudanese 2014-07-23 04:35:55 By Mahmoud A. Suleiman July 22, 2014 - This article comes against the backdrop of the news that reported the announcement of the National Elections Commission (NEC) that it had prepared the (...)

Bashir rests assured laden-burden on the Sudanese people’s shoulders 2014-07-14 06:09:16 By Mahmoud A. Suleiman July 13, 2014 - Omer al-Bashir believes that his continuing in power better protects him from tracking and prosecution by the International Criminal Court (ICC). He clings (...)

Lack of equity: A cause of many conflicts in Africa 2014-07-14 06:05:33 By Francis Ayul Yuar Nyok July 13, 2014 - It should be kept in mind that Africa crisis is not unique, more or less all the countries of the Sub-Sarah Africa are plague with acute poverty and in (...)


MORE








Latest Press Releases


Memory, healing and transformation in South Sudan 2014-07-23 05:55:08 Memory, Healing and Transformation in South Sudan A Working Paper by David K. Deng July 2014 Contents Introduction 1 What is memorialization? 2 Timing 2 Risks 3 Principles 3 Integrity 3 (...)

South Sudan: Independence Day marred by ongoing war crimes and looming famine 2014-07-09 01:39:56 AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL PRESS RELEASE 8 July 2014 South Sudan: Independence Day marred by ongoing war crimes and looming famine · Both sides to the conflict committing war crimes and crimes (...)

UN urged to probe alleged cover-ups and manipulations by its mission in Darfur 2014-06-26 05:40:52 Strengthen Peacekeeping Mission’s Rights Reporting, Civilian Protection (New York, June 25, 2014) – The United Nations secretary-general should investigate alleged cover-ups and manipulation of (...)


MORE

Copyright © 2003-2014 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.