Tuesday, Feb 9th, 2010 21:02 UTC
ar rss
Home page > Comments > Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM?

Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM?

Tuesday 3 November 2009 printSend this article by mail

By Ding Yian Gai

November 2, 2009 — Competitive elections are integral characteristics of democracy. Ideally, elections facilitate the peaceful transfer of political power and make those who govern accountable to the electorate. Elections are symbolic empowerment of the people over their leaders and a communication channel between them at the same time.

In fact, the right to elections has been enshrined in international law. Most importantly elections have become part of the international peace-building strategy, which strongly links peace to democratic development.

Most internationally sponsored peace agreements nowadays stipulate the holding of free and fair elections after the interim period. Therefore, in the case of the CPA Article 1.8.3 stipulates that elections shall be conducted at all levels of the Sudan at the end of third year. Of course the two partners could not meet to this dateline for reasons best known to them. They are now scheduled for April 2009.

But the question to ask is: will elections in the South under the SPLM administration be free and fair? This million-dollar question rings in the mind of every southerner today. Before answering this question I would like to inform my readers that the SPLM is currently caught between two difficult positions: either to boycott elections or to participate. With poor performance in the last four years and marred by endemic corruption and insecurity in the south, the SPLM fears loosing the elections. On the other hand, boycotting elections would mean loosing America’s support. I will return to these issues later. Now let me go back our question. Will the elections be free and fair under the SPLM-controlled GOSS?

Of course elections under the SPLM-controlled GOSS can not be expected to be free and fair for very obvious reasons. First, the SPLM has been in power since 2005 and all this time has amassed considerable funds whether legally or illegally. These will be used to buy votes during the elections thereby creating an unfair competitive advantage over other political parties. There can only be fair competition among the parties if Article 69 of the National Elections Law 2009 is implemented. This will require that all officials, constitutional post holders included, resign before declaring their candidatures.

My second fear is that the SPLM may use violence and intimidation in its desperate attempts to win elections. Over the years during the liberation war violence has pervaded individual, social and political relations and has been used by the SPLM as a legitimate mode of political behaviour. Even long after the CPA the SPLM did not hesitate to use violence against its adversaries. Examples abound: the murder of NCP operative in Yambio, fatal attack on Dr. Lam bodyguards on Anakdiar-Malakal road during SPLM congresses and recently in Khartoum, the attack by SPLM students at a rally organised by SPLM-DC supporters. All these incidents are indicative that the SPLM is politically intolerant and although it has been calling for democratic transformation, it hardly implements it. Thus it is feared that political and civil liberties such as freedom of speech and freedom of movement may be restricted by the SPLM during the campaign and polling. Even before elections these fundamental rights and freedoms used to be denied by SPLM state governors, commissioners and SPLA commanders.

My third fear revolves around the “competitiveness” of the elections. The competitiveness nature of elections may aggravate existing social conflict and cleavages particularly the election of the president of GOSS and governors where different tribes are expected to compete. In competitive elections, it is sometimes true that groups that have had a chance to govern may run the risk of losing power. If this happens, incumbents may not take this lightly and therefore may mobilise their supporters in an attempt to influence the electoral process and outcome through threats, intimidation, rigging and violence.

The probability of this occurring in the coming elections is increased by the fact that the majority of the officials who will manage the elections and command those forces securing elections hail from same tribe and party. But the most obvious thing that the SPLM will do, if it has not done it already, is how to ensure that the upcoming elections are rigged in its favour. For the last five years the SPLM has proven that it has no experience and expertise to manage public affairs, no moral turpitude to keep public money, no nationalist sentiments to unite our people and no strategic wisdom to lead our people to the declared objectives.

Last but not least, the fact is that for twenty six good years the SPLM has been running its affairs by selection and not election. For the SPLM leaders elections are like a black hole in the universe which scientists describe as void and scary. The SPLM does not and will not accept its failures and will therefore employ all its wits and whims at its disposal to rig the elections come rain or shine.

Eng. Ding Yian Gai is an expert working in one of the GoSS Ministries and could be reached at dingyian@hotmail.com

reply

12 Forum messages

  • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 3 November 2009 05:32, by thieleling

    Mr. Ding Gai,

    There would never be a peaceful democratic political transfer of power under Salva Kiir’s dictatorship in south sudan. The rise of massive violence during this pre-election period in south sudan is testament to Kiir’s failed dictatorial leadership. Peace after election is simply a joke. Instead; there will be massive post-election violence if no serious political assassinations before the election.

    Anger over the corruption scandals ($ 2.7 billions recent & more) and Kiir’s ineffectiveness could lead to a military coup in south sudan. This is the only way to give a voice to the poor civilians being killed everyday by their own gov’t.

    Thanks

    reply

    • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 3 November 2009 05:51, by Mr Famous Big_Logic_Boy

      Under Riek or Igga it will be, but under weak bettery like Kiir nothing only get prepared to face the disaster. Just imgaine what is happening at the moment under his leadership? the lost of lives in western Equatoria and Central Equatoria by LRA, Lake, Upper nile, Jungle and Bar el Gazel by dinkas, plus in Eastern Equatoria by turkana and korumojang. The answer is nothing and preparation is only thing we have to do. Thousdands of lives will flow in South like water in river nile, if you don’t believe wait and you will see.

      reply

      • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 3 November 2009 14:20, by WILFRED BOL

        What do you mean by Riek or Igga, it will be? Poor calculations about the national matters is how somebody commences belittling oneself.

        The growing insecurity is regularly reportrd day &night allover the ten states simultaneously even in Kiir’s state.

        Don’t you hear?Some of the powers have been devolved/transferred/delegated to state executives and nothing has not been achieved yet through this DECENTRALIZATION OF POWER.Be reasonable, realistic, intuitive and logic my friend.We can’t assume that there are some few individuals in this hard time to be better than some body else.Let us nurse the whole issue rather than pointing our fingers. Anonymous

        reply

    • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 5 November 2009 02:32, by braveheart

      I don’t think SPLM nor NCP have a record to conduct a positive and fair election, just waite and see...

      reply

  • Sir,

    You’re entiled to say whatever you want, but you have a misguided opinion, one that reflects nave position. Your suggestion that the electoral process is controlled by the officials belonging to one tribe is nonsense. The ten states of South Sudan cannot be under one tribe at any particular time. No ideal situation will support what you’re saying. The right question we need to ask is that will elections under the watch of the NIF be free and fair? We need to ask this question because the NIF has no interest in democratic transformation of Sudan, but the SPLM is the only political force working to foster freedom and democracy. Hence, you have just wasted your time and energy writing something that does not worth the page on which it is written.

    Kur

    reply

    • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 5 November 2009 20:08, by Deng Gatluak

      Kur,

      There is no different between Dinkas SPLM and Arab NIF or NCP when it comes to democratic transformations. The Dinkas SPLM had failed horrorably to implement democracy in the South Sudan and the same to NIF in North and Sudan in general that forced Darfurians went wild in west Sudan.

      Indeed the SPLM, ruling party in the South Sudan is one tribe political party. Its leader has appointed all government positions in South Sudan that is completely contrary to so-called democratic transformations sign. You needed to be logical Mr. kur rather than being politically motivated to defend your tribal leader.

      Remeber this defending a horrorable image as looting public funds, oppointed only ones’s tribalsmen to high government offices and spearheahed insecurity in South Sudan, its like dog eats its own vomiting in bright daylight.

      Its Dinkas dirty job that will be brought down by South Sudanese people in the near future, either politically or miltarily. Marginalizion was one that forced us to take arms against North oppressors and we must just do that against oppressors Dinkas who highly misused their chances of ruling the South for their own selfishness.

      dengnyayiel

      reply

  • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 3 November 2009 05:59, by Oduck Bol

    Move out in south or get yourself a gun and be ready for the action day. Any house that built from wrong tools and on wrong place will clap quickly. You see now everybody has doubt on system of south Sudan.I wounder some time people want to lead and at the same time they carry a huge tribalism and haterate in their hearts. Those tow will not go together.

    reply

    • Ding Gai,

      Election under SPLM would only be made unsuccessful and undemocratic by chaotic elements like those who had been causing insecurity in the region. Tribal elements may try to enforce their will by voting for unqualified and untruthworthy tribal leaders. This should not be blamed on SPLM because SPLM is not a tribe but the government which is composed of all.

      Also since this would be the first time our people would exercise the right of election, the people may be lacking skills on how to elect leaders. The ticket which would be used is tribal.

      Good enough that the presidency of southsudan is not going to be contested because Kiir will be there. Anyone who would rig the election to get the vice president or governor position is none of our business.

      reply

    • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 6 November 2009 14:53, by Hassan Ali Deng

      Oduck Bol I guess, you are talking about Oyay Deng who has transferred that huge fenced block with blue (arched)stores, south of Jebel Kujur on your left hand side on Juba Yei road from a property of SPLA to his own property. As per tribalism, Oyay successfully send to Shilluk all the weapons captured from SAF in Torit battle. Furthermore, Pagan Amum has turned SPLM to be his own party. For God sack, how could a rulling party fail to conduct one political rally. The answer is simple: Pagan is planning distroy SPLM and join Shilluk DC. How could a tribe which contributed nothing in struggle be honoured this way. Shame on you revolution thieves. Could any of you believes that Games Oth has a hot line mobile connection with Lam Akol!. Traiters...who is then firm to the course....Riek?...are you kigdding?...check on all skulls across the south..who’s would you find....

      reply

  • Will there be free and fair elections under the SPLM? 3 November 2009 07:34, by Akol Liai Mager

    Uh-Humm, "Eng. Ding Yian Gai is an expert working in one of the GOSS Ministries". This description I have just quoted above is a problem by itself.

    But let me correct one thing from my Anonymous Article writer. (A) Lam Akol was attacked by Cattle raiders and not SPLM nor Dinka-SPLA if there is anything existed in the South by this name Dinka-SPLA. (B) Then, Lam Akol was a leading SPLM member. Or is it because Lam Akol is always a "non-SPLM leader" when things go to the directions of his dislike, and "him" when things go his interest? Lam once said; "I am not a foreign minister of the SPLM or South, SPLM did not qualified me to be a minister in the GoNU." I don’t want to say more about this because it has been argued and exhausted by Dandara Ali Dandara by the time it came to the surface.

    Well, Lam Akol may be right on the first part of his statement, but the fact is that SPLM is the one who was given foreign ministry porfolio following CPA Power division, and SPLM assigned him to that position, and not the opposite.

    Dear, Anonymou engineer, if you are not lam Akol yourself, you have discredited and imprisoned yourself in the prison of fear simply because your motivation is spying and spiers do not necessary need to tell truth since telling truth will uncover their identities. So, your mistakes here are more about wasting readers time than your lies occuying a space on this web.

    Just to ask you some questions, why did you fail to see or ask NIF leaders; especially Al-Bashir to step down from his positions as President and Cief of the Northern Army after being decleared NIF Presidential Candidate while you are able to see that in the SPLM? Or do you think northern Sudan is not part of your Sudan any more? Are you afraid of telling this to NIF leaders, or are eager for blackmailing SPLM because you are not made a minister, or what are your prblems exactly?

    Please, can I just give you some tips and feel free to use or reject them as you want? Read commentaries in Arabic Racist newspaper of Ra’ay NIF the so-called ra’yaam, especially those written by Ra’shid Abdelrahim, Dhia al-deen Balal and their racist master-minded Ismail Al-Attabani. Read commentaries written by Mostafa Siri and Sidgi Kaballo in Sudanile commentaries site.

    After reading those commentaries you may discover what a writer does to build their own world attractive to their readers. Despite Attabani, Ra’shid and Dhia-Al-deen eager to maliciously attack SPLM, GOSS and Southerners, I have an interest to read their rubbish because what the enemy say can be beneficial sometimes.

    I pologise if I used some words that might have hurt because I do not meant to hurt, I simply meant to argue things that are not beneficial to the case between the so-called "Awallad Al Belled" on one hand, and African Sudanese on the other.

    reply

    • Gatwech, my penis inside your ass;

      First, suck my dick!

      The report by your Nuer narrow-minded reporter Gatdet Dak was meant to discredit Kiir and also to make him be sacked by Bashir and replace him with your dwarf-brain leader Riek Machar. That dream will not happen under our watch! The foolish Nuer will try by all mean to snatch power from Kiir but they will miserably fail.

      GATWECH, FUCK YOUR ASS AND FUCK YOUR MUM’S PUSSY!

      reply

      • Gatwech,

        Did you actually read what Door wrote? How come that he can fuck the pussy you where born?

        I can’t tolerate it. You need to be respectful to people on the website otherwise people will write bad stuffs about you. You must have done something bad to this guy given your Nuer-narrow-mindedness.

        Respect and act wisely or else the guy will write worst about you. I know Nuer chaotic manners would be difficult for you to overcome as you interact with others but you must adjust.

        It is weird that someone can fuck your ass and fuck your mum pussy which you were born. Is that what you want?

        reply

Copyright © 2003-2010 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.