Home | News    Thursday 8 May 2008

Sudanese investigators complete preliminary probe on plane crash


May 7, 2008 (KHARTOUM) — Sudanese investigators have completed the gruesome task of sifting through the wreckage of the Beech 1900 that crashed last week and started preparing their technical report.

JPEG - 10.8 kb
Salva Kiir Mayardit (R) and Vice-President Riek Machar (C) stands on May 6, 2008 in Juba during a burial ceremony for South Sudan’s late Defence minister Dominic Diem Deng (AFP)

Due to technical failure a plane of South Sudan Air Connection came down on Friday May 2, 375 kilometers from Juba, killing everyone on broad including South Sudan army minister Dominic Dim Deng and Justin Yac Arop, GoSS presidential Adviser for Decentralization.

The deputy director of the Sudan Civil Aviation Authority and member of the technical investigation team, Mohamed Saleh al-Kenani said the investigators had visited the site of the accident, 15 km east of Rumbek, and returned to Khartoum carrying the black box, which should explain why the Beechcraft crashed.

He further said that the black box will be sent to the nearest examination centre outside Sudan by the competent authorities very soon.

Following the crash, the civilian aviation authority disclosed that it had blamed GoSS minister of transport for authorising private foreign companies to operate in south Sudan without examining their planes by its competent service.

South Sudanese officials said following the accident that the plane’s captain reported engine trouble and requested an emergency landing in Rumbek airstrip. But the plan crashed before reaching the airport.

Gabriel Changson Chan, southern Sudan’s information minister, told the Sudanese TV last Friday that most of the planes operating in South Sudan are ancient and not technically controlled.


Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 8 May 2008 08:55, by Toposa Boy southerner

    Khartoum the terrorist city is to take care of the black box
    Southerners are finish

    repondre message

  • 8 May 2008 16:30, by young paul

    You got it right is time Toposa Boy Southern, although most of the time I don’t agree with you, but that is the pattern of live. Can you tell me why H.E Kiir , is crying and H.E Machar is not, has it to do with tribalism emotional control or Twic community heart breaking . This picture need to by analyst by UN experts so we don’t waste our time dreaming for a fail country.

    repondre message

    • 9 May 2008 11:11, by justin wani

      young paul:

      Can I know if you only want your name
      to appear on the Sudan tribune or you are out of your senses? Why are you kidding yourself to the entire world, it’s really a pity for a southern Sudan citizen to reason in that way you are reasoning. Why are you putting your leaders into such achildish thinking which is played by kids while taking care of cattle in the bush. you would have suggested of a solution on how to cover this painful unforgettable wound left to us as the citizens of southern Sudan for the lose of our beloved leaders and those who perished with them in the plane crash,other than bringing our leaders and tell to the world who cried and who didn’t,please don’t bring this big blow to the southern Sudan into games or joks. be gentle and think first before you post your empty understanding

      repondre message

  • 8 May 2008 18:15, by Ben-Fu

    Although no one can predict what is a head of us, I can see failure from our leaders.

    If our leaders just sit and talk big days and nights nothing can happen automatically.

    Building Southern Sudan need unity, toughs’ actions and commitment with high security for our citizens to work and move freely.

    GOSS receive almost a billion $$ a year from oil and our high-ranking official still renting19 century old stagnant engine planes.

    Since GOSS has not taken measures on national security, insecurity can always rise higher and we can always talks about security after disastrous tragic like this one.

    We can always talks about disbarments after one tribe attacks others fiercely.
    No attacks, forget the disarmament and insecurity.
    What is GOSS doing?

    1.Tribal disputes are ignored saying they can do nothing about it, the same lame excuse use by Khartoum on Darfur.

    2. Our leaders are looking for more oil well everywhere in southern Sudan to sell to foreigners. Yes, GOSS is doing their best delivering service to the citizens!

    3. They enjoy lives in big cities, e.g. Juba and Khartoum, others Southern major town? Forget it, no fresh fruit, because no agricultural agenda on the land.

    They are building roads but no bulldozers though, so let foreign businessmen buy and do the development.

    Old planes are painted to look new and we are poor, population wouldn’t know.
    Only Khartoum can take care of the black box, GOSS has no budget and knowledge to take care of such high-tech incident.

    Ha ha ha soon we will become "Laughing Stock"!

    repondre message

  • 9 May 2008 02:33, by Dhieu Dok

    Young Paul

    It does not mean that everyone should cry when the president is crying. Salva Kiir didn’t even cry when Dr. Garang’s plane crashed if my memory is still sharp. You may correct me on that point.

    This is a lost not only to South Sudan in general but a big blow in his own backyard. There is no point of questioning why Riek is not crying. It is up to him to cry or not depending on how he is haunted by the lost. Suppose the plane that crahsed carried people from Leer in Unity State, you would have seen Riek crying the same way.

    In a nutshell, my own analysis is that Salva Kiir is haunted by the big lost from his own backyard of Twic Mayardit. And I sympathized with him because those guys were very important to him.

    Let’s look at the flip side of it. Will crying help? How long will black boxes be taken to foreign land for interpretation? The last black box from Garang’s plane was taken to Russia. The current one is being analyzed by our enemies. How do we expect the people in Khartoum to be objective in the investigation? Let’s think about that for time being.


    repondre message

    • 10 May 2008 09:24, by Khot Majok Tuil

      By khot Majok in Australia
      i would like to alert every one on this site that this site was made automatically for us to expess our productive ideas and endorse them to entire world,why are we using it as a place of dumping nonsense of divisions and tribalism.

      It is better for all of us to joint up together adheisively do something and tell the entire world what is going on in our country, why do they used the rabbish plane or what ever they call it to fly in our condusive country,the plane that would have been dopsite to recycling bin.

      My worry is the black box, i don’t expect any possitive outcome if it is still on the hand of those foolish and stupid enemies(arab)
      thanks.khot majok

      repondre message

  • 9 May 2008 04:15, by sudanson

    As long as southerners failed to build their institutions like aviation, medical, educational, their will be no way out, presently there have been failure fromt he top to train their own pilots and their on engineers even after the leader of splm Garang crached in the helicopter, authorities have failed to purchase good planes for top commanders and ministers, plane will cost less than $20-30 million for one good plane or helicopter, see how much money south have from oil is almost about $1.6 billion, from this money why the GOSS leader cannot take just $50-100 million and use buy new plane and train pilots na dengineers for south sudan?, this would be able to save the lifes of remaining commanders and top officials.
    If GOSS acted early this people who died would not have died.
    As long as south government and president do not do the right work at the right time more people will continue to die and the enemy will continue to count the dead & analyse the black boxes for them.

    repondre message

    • 9 May 2008 07:30, by Nyibol Maker

      Dear Dhieu,

      You are pretty right bro, crying won’t help us in any way! It’s like crying for the spilled milk which can not be recollected once they are spilled. But in one way or the other, we can say that this milk was spilled accidentally. What about our lost great heros, can anyone say that it was by accident that they died? May yes because accidents are bound to occur when least expected, but again, i can say that if we know that the cause of the accident was something that could be controlled, then we can’t really say that they died accidentally because something would have done since the last incident of Lt. Dr. J.G.de-Mabior.

      To Sudanson,

      Brother, this is the truth i was talking about on my previous post if at all you came across it by any chance. Like you said, of course, GOSS has got the resources to make a real change to its area as well as its people, but it just seems to lack the proper skills, the visions, or the plans to improve itself. Look at Lt. Dr. John, why was he regarded as a man of vision, wasn’t it because he wanted to bring freedom to the South and he did it? Likewise to our current leaders, they’ve somehow got the vision, but lack of unity, corruption, nepotism, self-satisfaction, and may more, are pulling them back from achieving thier dreams. And so the question is, WHAT THEN ARE WE GONNA DO?
      To me, i would say that, we would rather say the truth and ashame the devil and the leaders to turn away from all thier personal desires and things that could be destructing them from accomplishing the task of making South a better place to live in. UNITY!!!!!!!
      PEACE!!!!!!! LOVE!!!!!!!

      repondre message

      • 9 May 2008 10:18, by Daniel Kalaka

        Oh God!!! what if we cry day and night what can we benefit from doing it as time is passing by.

        The only thing Goss leaders have to do is to treat the real cause route rather then treating the sympots of what happen.

        Thirdly Goss have to surpose to handle such issue than given it under Custody of NCP to See into the cause of plane crash because if they depend on that there is no way out for them to revile out the result the same like what happen to our hero Man of Wisdom ,Vision ,prediction of new sudan .

        Fourthly,to sacrify for the sake of nation is better than to offer for your own genus ,look this terrorist in khartoum starts with our hero & others and in the same way they are carrying unneccassery massacres in Darfur are ready for everything if you don’t get solution for crashes going on Mr H.E president.

        repondre message

  • 9 May 2008 16:21, by young paul

    For Justin Wani

    Justin Wani, from your name I can tell that you come from those backward primitive tribes that marry their women with chickens. I posted a genuine question to enlighten your crispy brain that Southern Sudan are wired mental in this chronicle disease call tribalism .For sure Dhieu Dok, answered my question and explained it further that if that plane had crushed carry some people from” leer” Nuer community Dr Machar would have fainted crying. So for a moron like you to think that my posting make no sense, raises my doubt that probably you need a physistirc reevaluation to bring you to the capacity of my mental thinking. Have a good day Wani my Juba little boy. I pity no fools and watch out I can go hard on you.

    repondre message

    • 12 May 2008 16:39, by Yaac John

      In referrance to what Dr.Riek said during the plane crash which kill our Defence minister with other official,iam afraid if out vice president is going to be our expert then he will block us from seeing who is behind our death.

      repondre message

  • 16 May 2008 11:54, by Afonso

    I am a non Sudanese and has always been supporting the liberation of South Sudan, but after a visit to South Sudan few months back, I was shocked at what I saw. I am now convinced that all the years poor southerners spent fighting has just gone in vain due to the following points
    1.The GOSS bosses are always busy with ladies and beer at the hotels in JUba
    2.Almost the GoSS bosses have their families and expensive houses outside Sudan (Kampala, Nairobi, Addis etc)
    3. GoSS Ministers are busy dating and spending high amount of money on foreign girls in Juba whilst neglecting their legal wives in poor houses in Juba
    4. There are no good or standard houses in Juba
    5. Only 2 good roads for the whole of Juba
    6. Poor communication network only an illrgal mobile phone system "Gemtel" operates in Juba and part of the South
    7 Its expensive travelling around as there are no roads only by air
    8 There is no power supply, since December 2007, all NGO and homes depend on generators
    9 THere is no pipeborne water supply 10 Indian hotel owners are importing labourers and workers and even tractor drivers from India at the detriment of young umemployed Sudanese youths
    With all these probelms was there any need to fight
    Presently almost all the GoSS bosses are owning the latest and most expensive cars, driving uselessly all over Juba and doing little or no work at all
    To see how effective many of these GoSS bosses are just visit hotel and bars and you would see that they dominate the entire place and some bluff of their weapons in the open
    What angers me most is that almost all the GoSS bosses live for months in these hotels and I ask myself why cant they go and live in their homes and thus develop the standards rather than live in these hotels paying over $100 daily on rooms not to talk about food and drinks. This reminds me of a book I read "Animal Farm" written by George Orwell. If the poor people knew this was going to be the outcome of their struggle, I am sure they would have refused to allow to be used for this useless fight.The only way forward is to force these GoSS buffoons out of their unnecessary expensive lifestyles and work for a better South Sudan

    repondre message

Comment on this article

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.

Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis

South Sudan’s universities should explore other revenues 2019-03-17 20:33:06 By Ukongo Benson Athia Of recent, it transpired that the five public universities dons have advanced their cause to increase the tuition fees for the students. I have seen such complaints of (...)

Pressure from the people in Sudan 2019-03-17 10:55:35 The longer genuine political and economic reform is delayed in Sudan, the greater the risk of wider instability and deepening economic crisis. By Rosalind Marsden President Omar al-Bashir, who (...)

Sudan’s al-Bashir burnt the boats before crossing 2019-03-11 06:19:03 By Mahmoud a. Suleiman Second Military Coup D’état of Omer Bashir will Not Protect him from his inevitable fate at the hands of the uprising Sudanese people The angry uprising men, women and (...)


Latest Press Releases

Sudan Protests: Investigate the custodial death of three University students 2019-03-13 12:53:14 The African Centre for Justice and Peace Studies (ACJPS) Sudan Protests: Urgent call for investigations into the custodial death of three University students and alleged torture of detainees by (...)

The Alliance for Restoration of Sudanese Workers Trade Unions Joins the Declaration of Freedom and Change 2019-03-10 21:16:50 PRESS RELEASE For immediate release 10 th March 2019 The Alliance for Restoration of Sudanese Workers Trade Unions announced on Sunday 10th March that it was joining the revolutionary forces (...)

Ethnic Murle politicians say enough to cattle raiding 2018-12-28 09:32:00 December 27, 2018 (JUBA) - Murle political leaders in Buma state have vowed to end the practice of cattle raiding and child abduction by individuals in the community. Jodi Jonglei, who is also (...)


Copyright © 2003-2019 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.