Home | News    Wednesday 20 June 2007

Sudan a failed state? Depends where you live


By Opheera McDoom

June 19, 2007 (KHARTOUM) — With eight-lane highways adorned by huge television screens advertising Sudanese companies, Khartoum does not appear to fit the image of capital of the world’s most failed state.

But an index published by U.S.-based Foreign Policy magazine on Monday placed Sudan at the top of just such a list, ahead of even Iraq and Somalia.

Arriving in Khartoum’s pristine, refurbished airport terminal, visitors are greeted by a huge glass Toyota showroom with the newest model vehicles.

Testament to Sudan’s new oil wealth, pumping more than 500,000 barrels per day, high-speed wireless is available, mobile networks compete for new customers. And cafes serving French pastries have sprung up throughout Khartoum, one of the safest capitals in Africa.

But analysts attribute that to the strength of the security apparatus in Khartoum, the base of the government, and the city’s wealth to its concentration of international business.

Outside Khartoum is a different story. There, the Foreign Policy index begins to make more sense.

Foreign Policy’s researchers used indicators such as public services, human rights, security apparatus, displaced populations, territorial control and relations with the international community to measure a state’s success or failure.

It found Sudan was the most failed state in the areas of numbers of refugees and displaced people, group grievances against the state, the delegitimisation of the state, and human rights abuses.

"The primary cause of (Sudan’s) instability, violence in the country’s western region of Darfur, is as well known as it is tragic," Foreign Policy said.

It added that Darfur violence had affected Chad and Central African Republic, which have suffered as the conflict spilled over the border. Chad is No. 4 on the list and CAR No. 10.

"The spillover effects from Sudan have a great deal to do with the countries’ tumble in the rankings, demonstrating that the dangers of failing states often bleed across borders," the magazine said.


Outside the rapidly developing city centre, Khartoum’s sprawling slum suburbs, home to millions who have fled regional conflicts throughout Africa’s largest country, do not have electricity, running water, or proper healthcare.

In the peripheral regions, the situation is worse.

"By any standards other than the economy of Khartoum (and) the immediate region, Sudan is a profoundly failed state," said U.S. academic and activist Eric Reeves.

A bitter north-south war, which has blown on and off since independence half a century ago killing 2 million people, ended with a 2005 peace deal that formed an autonomous southern government and a right to vote on secession.

But Sudan’s oil-rich central Abyei region is in dispute.

A Darfur peace deal has done little to quell violence in Sudan’s west, where international experts estimate 200,000 have been killed. An eastern peace deal has seen little progress.

And in the north, violence has erupted as authorities try to move people from land they want to flood to build a dam.

The conflicts have forced some 7 million people from their homes.

After threats of sanctions and international isolation, Sudan accepted a joint U.N.-African Union peacekeeping force for its western Darfur region of 20,000-25,000 troops and police.

Around 11,000 U.N. forces already patrol the south.

This will leave half Sudan’s around 32 million population under international protection.

Foreign Ministry Spokesman Ali al-Sadig said the facts on the ground proved Sudan was not a failed state. Sudan has signed three regional peace deals in two years.

"We don’t take such things seriously," Sadiq said of the index, "mainly because the facts do not indicate that Sudan is the way they depict it."


But analysts all agreed democratisation was necessary for Sudan and those enjoying the fruits of foreign investment should not expect it to last forever.

"Unless the pattern of rapacious elite governance that has characterized Sudan for decades changes, the mounting process of disintegration and genuine state failure will only gain momentum," said Lawrence Rossin, a former U.S. ambassador.

"Sudan could become a failed state due to the actions of its own government," he added.

Rossin said pressure was needed to encourage a fundamental change in governance. President Omar Hassan al-Bashir took over in 1989 in a bloodless coup and has ruled since.

Political parties and regional rebel groups have factionalised leaving little effective or united opposition.

"Until such sustained international pressure is exerted, half the people of Sudan will need protection - from their own government," said Rossin.

Sudan expert John Ashworth said: "Morally Sudan is a failed state. ... For Sudan to become a strong moral state needs ... a change in the basic power structure which keeps an unrepresentative minority in power."


Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 20 June 2007 04:13, by xasan

    Those who created death squads and funded the civil wars in Somalia, Sudan and Iraq accuse us of being failed states. The fact the matter is all three nations have shown their independence from western domination. As a result, West have invaded Iraq, funded the rebel groups in Sudan, and funded the merciless warlords in Somalia and when they were overthrown by the Islamic Courts Union, invited Ethiopia to invade Somalia while they were providing logistics, weapons, training and also air power to the invading Ethiopian troops.

    repondre message

    • 20 June 2007 16:06, by John Mabior Malekdit

      Only failed states commit genocides against their own citizens.

      It looks that the Arab North will live with this myth of a ’democratic Sudan under the caring government of Omer Albashir’.Just like it deludes them for all these years to know that the simmering conflict in the South was not a Southern problem but a Sudan problem,these lunates seem not to know or don’t care to know;fo reasons obvious;that Sudan as a country does not exist in practice.What we have are people call Sudanese,It is a fact that these Sudanese donot live in one country call Sudan but in ’Sudans’.How else then cann’t we be categorised as ’a failed state’, by countries that demonstrated maturity in handling their national issues and cared for their citizens in a most responsible way.Those are the inevitable consequences of a country governed by a criminal and Islamic fanatics blinded and drunk to his fill with Islamic dogmas loaded with greed and racialism,with such unfounded foible appoach went a head to cut loose the bonds that have tied the Sudanese together since independence rendering the country disfunctional and fragmented the country into Darfur,South and Eastern Sudan crisis that have produced the most vicious human tragedy ever recorded since the second Wold war.As if outraged by the consequences of their own divissive policies responded with devilish precision by unleashing the most tragic mass killing;rape,pillage and balkanisation of the entire country into tiny tribes,militias etc that are always at each other’s throat each one doing the bidding for the regime exploding the janjaweed,Murhalin saga that tails the Sudanese human tagedy over the last 20 years and is still ongoing.Those who ranked Sudan did it a favour by describing it merely as ’one of the most failed state’.Sudan deserve a more low place in global pespective and its place at the global stage should be equivilent only to hell.
      Mabior Malekdit

      repondre message

Comment on this article

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.

Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis

South Sudan’s universities should explore other revenues 2019-03-17 20:33:06 By Ukongo Benson Athia Of recent, it transpired that the five public universities dons have advanced their cause to increase the tuition fees for the students. I have seen such complaints of (...)

Pressure from the people in Sudan 2019-03-17 10:55:35 The longer genuine political and economic reform is delayed in Sudan, the greater the risk of wider instability and deepening economic crisis. By Rosalind Marsden President Omar al-Bashir, who (...)

Sudan’s al-Bashir burnt the boats before crossing 2019-03-11 06:19:03 By Mahmoud a. Suleiman Second Military Coup D’état of Omer Bashir will Not Protect him from his inevitable fate at the hands of the uprising Sudanese people The angry uprising men, women and (...)


Latest Press Releases

Sudan Protests: Investigate the custodial death of three University students 2019-03-13 12:53:14 The African Centre for Justice and Peace Studies (ACJPS) Sudan Protests: Urgent call for investigations into the custodial death of three University students and alleged torture of detainees by (...)

The Alliance for Restoration of Sudanese Workers Trade Unions Joins the Declaration of Freedom and Change 2019-03-10 21:16:50 PRESS RELEASE For immediate release 10 th March 2019 The Alliance for Restoration of Sudanese Workers Trade Unions announced on Sunday 10th March that it was joining the revolutionary forces (...)

Ethnic Murle politicians say enough to cattle raiding 2018-12-28 09:32:00 December 27, 2018 (JUBA) - Murle political leaders in Buma state have vowed to end the practice of cattle raiding and child abduction by individuals in the community. Jodi Jonglei, who is also (...)


Copyright © 2003-2019 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.