Home | Comment & Analysis    Thursday 14 December 2006

Reflections on the Anuak Genocide

separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation

By Apee Ojulu *

Dec 13, 2006 — Early in this century, at a university in the U.S, a professor asked all students to introduce themselves to the class. Among students, there were an Anuak seated in one of the first few rows and a Highlander Ethiopian seated in the last row. When introduction reached the Anuak, he introduced himself as an Ethiopian and Ethiopian Highlander introduced herself as an Ethiopian. Instead of letting other students behind her introduce themselves, she added that the Anuak was from Gambella and she was from Ethiopia despite the fact Gambella is a part of Ethiopia in international map.

In disputing the Anuak citizenship status as not Ethiopian, she repeated the usually claims Anuak people and other Gambellans face when travel in other parts of Ethiopia. When Gambella people traveled in other parts of Ethiopia, many ruling Highlander Ethiopian elite label Gambellans as others, foreigners and potentially obstacle to the economic development and this perception played a largest role in the December 13, 2003 massacre against Anuak people.

The purpose of this essay on the third anniversary of the December 13 Anuak Genocide is to discuss its root causes and its aftermath. In discussing the root causes of the December 13 Anuak genocide it is intended neither to gather ammunition against Highlanders nor to fall to the same trap that they are less than human beings in arguing. My aim rather is to understand what is driving ruling Highlanders’ policies toward Gambellans. To understand it not excuse, just as to forgive is not to forget, but without understanding the principles driving the ruling Highlanders perceptions, no way to develop a new relationship that’s based on mutual understanding among respective communities. Yes, telling the truth hurt feelings but ignoring the truth to gain popularity is the most injurious thing one can do to those who fall victims like Anuak people.

The ruling Ethiopian Highlander elites see Gambella state in two faces. Gebrhab Barnabas, the Federal Minister for states affairs under Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, told the U.S. based Journalist Doug McGill during a meeting in Addis Ababa that Gambella, if developed properly, could feed the entire country of Ethiopia. But he has hardly any praise for inhabitants of the region. Barnabas labeled people calling for fair administration of justice in the region as scams in the front of McGill. Ethiopian Highlanders elite praise the state rich in resources, land, tree, gold, and oil, but not the inhabitants.

A Gambellan in psychic of the ruling Higlander Ethiopians is an object there nothing more than dealing with at such. The people of Gambella their presence are questioned. In his paper on the December 13, 2003, Dereje Fayssia writes that “the Anywaa are said to have migrated to their present-day settlements since the 18th century.” Many Ethiopians over the debate on issue of genocide have argued using this historical perspective that Anuak people in running to Sudan for their safety have returned to their rightful land. This claim really is totally fault view of the history of Anuak and other Gambellans. Anuaks inhabited Gambella for centuries and true historians have confirmed this view. Even if Gambellans started arriving in 1800s, which they are not, they would still be the owners of the Gambella. Ethiopia extended its control only in 1900s when, by this dating, most Gambellans were already settled in the land. Gambella became part of Ethiopia in 1956 as a result of 1902 Rod Agreement and the demarcation Agreement of 1956.

In major cities such Jimma, Addis Ababa Ethiopian highlanders see Gambellans as “Lomn.” Lomn is an Amharic word equivalent to the word Negro use against blacks in the United States. It is means literally Gambellans are slaves. Other names given to Gambellans are Nigerians, Ghanaians, Sudanese or Kenyans. By labeling Gambellans these names as slaves or as foreigners in their own country, Gambellans are seen potentially as others who are not citizens. Some Gambellans frustrated by being called Lomn or outright slave, often preferred to be called Nigerians or Kenyan in the belief by being given these foreign names they are bit better than being called slaves.

But the extent of erasing the footprints of Gambellans in the land extended far more to their local landmarks that have historical significance. One important example is the renaming of Openo River. In Gambella, there are four major rivers: namely Akobo River, Gilo River, Alworo River, and Openo River. Openo River is the biggest and Alworo River the smallest. With arrival of Ethiopia in the region, Ethiopians renamed Openo River as Baro River. By renaming the river Baro River, Ethiopians disconnected Gambellans to their river and gives the legitimacy to their claims over the river.

The debate over the issue of oil exploration in Jor, Gambella other challenges that have made depicting Gambellans as foreigners important. Oil fields were discovered in the northern part of Gambella in the last half of last century by some foreign oil companies. For some logistic and other reasons, the previous communist regime did not started exploring oil after it was discoursed then. In the recent years, the present regime in Addis Ababa has made exploring as one of its top priorities. But instead of working with regional citizens to develop it for the benefit of the regional development and share with the federal government, the government made missteps that put it on a collusion course with Gambellans. The government announced to take oil from Gambella and refinery it in Jimma. This immediate caused Gambellans to reject the government attempt to explore the oil. Instead of working with Gambellans, some in the government have labeled Gambellans as foreigners who are preventing oil exploration.

Many Ethiopian Highlanders defended the government of Prime Minister Meles Zenawi in reaction to the news of the initial killing of over 425 Anuak people innocent civilians by accusing Anuaks as were the ones who have started the killings after the initial reporting. Dereje Feyssia’s paper is important here because his view represent the pluralist view of Ethiopian Highlanders. In his paper he claims that “what happened on December 13, 2003 was a violent expression of the highlanders’ pent up grievances. It was preceded by a series of indiscriminate killings of the highlanders by army Anywaa groups.”

But in claiming that Anuaks were the ones behind the killings of United Nations’ personnel, Feyissa did not have evident to back him up then his long beliefs about Anuaks that they are others, foreigners and obstacle to the state future. There was no any investigation undertaken by the government to investigate the incident thoroughly and determine the people behind the killings. The government knew had there been an investigation into the killing, the investigation could have up with the true killers. Outside Gambella town where the killing occurred there were three different armed group. The Oromo Liberation Front and remnants of the previous communist regime under Thaut actively operated in the areas with known attacks against the government. No one waits for investigation to find out the killers. Anuak people were hastily selected as the killers, criminals and troublemakers because of their beliefs that all Gambellans are others, foreigners and potentially obstacle to the state future.

Even opposition supporters and their leaders in Washington and in many cities who first came to the Anuaks’ defend held the same views that Anuaks are foreigners and potentially obstacle to their country’s economic development. These opposition leaders and supporters wanted Anuaks to condemn the regime alone. As Chombe, one of the opposition supporters wrote: “Never accuse the Ethiopian people for the crime TPLF regime committed.” It is true that the killing of Anuak people on December 13, 2003 was an operation under the leadership of the Meles regime.

But that operation was not an operation Meles regime took alone without the help and participation of other highlanders. There were many civilian highlanders allied to the regime who assisted the Ethiopian troops by going door to door with them and knocked doors of the victim Anuak people slain them in front of their families with machetes.

* The writer is a citizen of the greater East Africa area and is the Editor of www.gambelatoday.com, a website which is devoted to publishing news and commentaries on issues concerning Sudan Gambella state and Ethiopia. He can be reached at api@gambelatoday.com



The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it to comment@sudantribune.com

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication. Please include your full name, relevant personal information and political affiliations.
Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 12 October 2007 03:36, by Berhan Sebhat

    Letter to the Editor on Crimes Against Humanity
    May 07, 2007

    I came across an article written by an Ethiopian anthropologist which is to be presented in a late May, 2007 at Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The publication was extensive and well documented with an impressive citations, although some of them were unpublished dissertations and others were in Amharic with the author’s discretion on translation. The paper was on the Anuak people’s psyche relating to the infringement by other local ethnicities on their society. The paper was given to me by my long time family friend and brother Magn for my review. The paper was by Dr. Dereje Feyissa of the Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology in Germany. I have been following the tragedy which has been unfolding in Gambella leading to the systematic and brutal attempt to eliminate Anuaks. Therefore, the paper is timely since the carnage in Gambella is still ongoing according to the human right watch and others. I admit to my lack of a comprehensive study of the Anuak history and culture besides the many conversations that I have had with others. I have read most of the reports written on the genocide by organizations such as the UN, Human right watch and Genocide Watch.

    My interest in writing this opinion was triggered after reading an article on Gambela today written by the editor Mr. Apee Ojulu. It is not my attempt to criticize Dr. Dereje since I have neither the knowledge nor the confidence to do that. The article was Dereje Feyissa: the Great Ethiopian Genocide Justifier, Jan. 28/2005. The content of the article in my opinion was harsh towards Dr. Dereje, but raises the very important question of how the educated elites become an instrument to justify political wrong doings. Any body can read the article posted by Mr. Ojulu by going to gambelatoday.com therefore I will not make an attempt to summarize it now but I will quote the following by him. “Dereje Feyissa theorized Anuaks were responsible for the local highlanders and Ethiopian government’s decision on December 13 2003 to massacre Anuaks in their ancestry land of Gambella”. Again I do not agree with the writer’s entire article about Dr. Dereje and I will not go as far as calling him an apologist or bias to the “Nuer who filled his wallet”. But I do agree with the above quote and Dr. Dereje seems to say “an eye for an eye”. This seemingly careless stand by a person who is considered an authority on Gambella is troubling and open to criticism. The so called experts are the ones who are at the fore front of the world’s source of information; therefore, all Africans should be weary of them. I do agree with Mr. Ojulu however when it comes to the biases that the Anuak massacre was approached by other Ethiopians.

    It is irresponsible of Dr. Dereje to suggest the campaign of massacres, repression and mass rape that lead to 424 killed, 200 wounded and 5,297 displaced was explained as retaliation for killings by Anuaks. Even if one agrees with his assessment of the events that preceded the Dec. 13-16, 2003 genocide, no one can come to the conclusion of justifiability. Dereje stated that some disfranchised ex police officers were liable for the isolated killings of highlanders, which finally was answered by the “more brutal’ retaliation against the Anuak (or Anywaa as he prefers it). The question is does an isolated attack on individuals justify annihilation of an ethnic group. Human Right Watch (March 24, 2005) concluded what happened in Gambella amounts to crime against humanity. The organization used the following logic, “under international law, an offense committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against civilian population is crimes against humanity.” Anyone can read the report by the Genocide Watch as reported by Keith Harmon Snow, to come to the same conclusion of crimes against humanity.

    Let me bring it home to many “high land” Ethiopians by drawing parallel with the war crimes committed by the fascist Italians. February19, 1937, a bomb was thrown towards a table the Italian ministry of defense Rodolfo Graziani and other officers were sitting. The attempt to kill him was unsuccessful. The next three days saw unparalleled brutality by the rampaging gangs of fascist soldiers remmenesant of what happened in Gambella. They used guns, hoes, machetes, axes, knifes and clubs to kill over 3000 innocent civilians. Those days have etched an image of the brutality of the fascist Italians in every Ethiopian for generation. February 19 (Yekatit 12) since then has been observed as a day of martyrs, and to the memory of those days a magnificent statue stands in Addis Ababa. There is an eerie similarity of that day with Dec. 13-16. We can even argue that the atrocities in Gambella are much worse, since they are committed by their own government and fellow countrymen.

    I implore other Africans to look at what is happening to other human beings as if it is happening to their own kind. We, Africans, are quick to condemn outsiders when they do us wrong but are reluctant when our own ethnicity is implicated. According to genocide watch, the Ethiopian government knew something wrong had happen but they say it was baseless when people already have died. “This gives the impression that somebody somewhere conceived as an idea that the best thing to do is finish Anuaks…” to paraphrase a quote on the report. To this day the Ethiopian government had absolved the military of wrong doing. This is to be expected from PM Meles, but it is shameful if any conscience human being should even attempt to give an explanation for this crime against humanity other than hate and racism. No Italian from Mussolini down was ever convicted to this day for war crimes against Ethiopian and Eritrean people. It will be a blotch against all of Ethiopia if the same finale happened to those who are responsible for the carnage and attempted genocide against the Anuak people.

    Berhan Sebhat, North Carolina.

    repondre message

  • 11 October 2010 14:29, by Responsive

    It is all fake !!! No civilian anuwak was killed deliberately

    repondre message



The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.


s
Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis


The New Sudan’s battling leaders 2017-08-22 23:22:09 By Salah Shuaib Following South Sudan’s recent miserable transformations, a large segment of Sudanese elites is greatly disappointed by how the New Sudan project ended in failure, bringing a (...)

The 62nd anniversary of Torit popular uprising 2017-08-17 00:23:12 By Arop Madut Arop As the people of the Republic of South Sudan mark and celebrate the 62nd anniversary of August 18th, 1955 Torit uprising, it would extremely be important to recall the events (...)

What is the value of water? 2017-08-14 21:28:25 By Innocent Ntabana When you and I breathe in fresh air, the amount I inhale affects you in no way. This is because air is abundant and so there’s plenty of it to go around. We actually take it (...)


MORE






Latest Press Releases


New group formed to gather Nuer in United States 2017-08-17 14:15:50 DECLARATION FOR THE FORMATION OF NUD TO BRING TOGETHER ALL NUER IN THE U.S.A Press Statement The Nuer Union For Development (NUD) The United State of America The State of Nebraska August 15, (...)

A prominent Sudan Women and Civil rights activist passed away 2017-08-14 21:09:47 The Strategic Initiative for Women in the Horn of Africa (SIHA) Khartoum, Sudan-August 14 2017 In the early hours of Saturday 12th August Fatima Ahmed Ibrahim, a renowned Sudanese leader of the (...)

HRW denounces "collective punishment" in South Sudan’s Wau 2017-04-15 07:06:48 Human Right Watch South Sudan: New Spate of Ethnic Killings Urgent Need for Justice; UN Should Increase Patrols in Wau (Nairobi, April 14, 2017) – Government soldiers and allied militias (...)


MORE

Copyright © 2003-2017 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.