Home page | News    Monday 31 October 2011

Sudan rules out Abyei swap deal with south

separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation

October 30, 2011 (KHARTOUM) – The Sudanese ruling party brushed aside an offer made yesterday by the Republic of South Sudan (RoSS) to fully resolve the issue of the disputed border region of Abyei, saying that it belongs to the north.

JPEG - 32.5 kb
FILE - A aerial view of looted items scattered on the ground in front of a deserted homestead on the outskirts of Abyei town (Reuters)

Pagan Amum, secretary general of the ruling Sudan People’s Liberation Movement (SPLM) in RoSS, told Reuters in an interview that they are prepared to offer oil at a discounted price, an unspecified amount of cash, and forgiveness of all arrears from oil sharing claimed by the South from the time before it gained independence last July.

"This is a package that in return the government of Sudan will ensure the territorial integrity of South Sudan by agreeing to transfer Abyei to the South and also ceasing any claims on areas on the border of Southern Sudan that they are claiming," Amum said.

The financial aspect of the deal appears made to lure the north which is struggling economically ever since the oil-rich south seceded.

But the ruling National Congress Party (NCP) in Sudan quickly rejected the idea.

The NCP spokesperson Ibrahim Ghandour, while addressing a rally at Sennar state in central Sudan said that Abyei belongs to the north and that it is not up for sale or compromise. He added that there is no room for retreat from the fact that it is part of Sudan.

"We will not compromise on Abyei and we will not allow the existence of two armies in the country,” Ghandour said.

The borders of Abyei were redrawn by the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in 2009 after the NCP & SPLM agreed to refer the matter to it in a bid to resolve the long standing dispute.

However, the technical commission mandated with demarcating the borders on the ground failed to start the process because of threats leveled by the Arab Misseriya tribe who objected to the PCA ruling.

The 2005 Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) signed between the NCP and SPLM stipulates that two simultaneous self-determination referendums should be held in South Sudan and Abyei so that its residents can decide their fate.

The SPLM has interpreted the ruling as meaning that the cattle-herding Misseriya tribe have no right to vote in areas assigned by the PCA to the Dinka Ngok. However, the Misseriya vow not to allow the vote to take place even if they have to resort to force unless they are allowed to participate.

The situation in the oil-rich region escalated dramatically last May when Sudan’s armed forces (SAF) invaded the area in response to an attack allegedly carried out by southern forces, two months before South Sudan gained independence from Khartoum.

Following mediation by the African Union (AU), both sides agreed to withdraw their forces and have them replaced by an Ethiopian peacekeeping force that was later named United Nations Interim Security Force for Abyei (UNISFA).

But signs of renewed tensions emerged again after Khartoum said that it will not pull its forces unless the AU-brokered Abyei accord is fully implemented.

(ST)

Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 31 October 2011 08:48, by Jalaby

    Thief Pagan Amum,
    Are you still a live?! I thought you steped down after Mr. Kiir sacked you out of RoSS cabinet because of your dishonesty, theft and childish activities! It’s just a matter of time till they will sack you from secretary general and you end up sitting at home!
    I suggest you to join south Sudan rebels and raise marginalization issue!

    Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 09:11, by Logic

      Another northern bigot upset with Pagan Amum because he tells like it is.

      Its funny how these racist wana-be-Arabs don’t like confrontation, hypocrites who like pretending to be one thing while living a different life. Khartoum is self evident of such contradictions. I pity the likes of the above commentator.

      Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 09:23, by Sam.Eto

        12 million delusional racists who think they own the world because god gave it to them ! Mind your own buisiness.

        Pagan is an alcoholic, Narcissistic, delusional zionist like the rest of you. You trained him well !! South Sudan doesnt even have the money to pay transit fees - But they want to buy Abyei - Shame on them. He does not hold the Abyei portfolio or oil - so Shut up Pagan.

        Reply to this message

        • 31 October 2011 09:33, by Logic

          History alone can contradict the above absurd comment about 12 million Southerners being racists. Get hold of a history book, drop your blind loyalty and you might learn something.

          The audacity of this criminal supporter calling southerners racists, what a joke! Probably half of the NCP are alcoholics and sodomizers of young boys.

          Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 09:37, by Logic

            One must distinguish between the mentality of the above racist northerners and the average northerner.

            The average northern Sudanese is also a victim of the brutal and oppressive policies of the NCP, unless they become indoctrinated and take on a supremacist attitude like the two above commentators.

            Reply to this message

            • 31 October 2011 09:50, by Logic

              Zionists??? really?? is that the best you can do, PATHETIC!

              Deprive African Sudanese of obtaining prominent land & education, make one religion the state religion, brutal crack down of the native inhabitants of the land, state sponsored social injustice in favor of one group (so called Arab Sudanese). Yet, you have the balls to compare southerners to Zionists?

              The NCP resembles Zionism.

              Reply to this message

              • 31 October 2011 09:59, by Sam.Eto

                Thanks your for defining Zionism for us.

                Reply to this message

                • 31 October 2011 10:06, by Master

                  Ha Ha Ha Ha ... I agree.

                  Zionism - Deprive ’Palestinian’ of obtaining prominent land & education, make one religion the state religion, brutal crack down of the native inhabitants of the land ’Palestinian’, state sponsored social injustice in favor of one group (Zionists). Its perfect ! it should be in a dictionary - Thanks logic.

                  Reply to this message

                  • 31 October 2011 16:57, by Logic

                    You’re welcome,

                    One cannot criticize the NCP and previous Khartoum elitists at the same time turn a blind eye to atrocities committed in Palestine. They’re cut from the same cloth, and you’re like the Israeli citizen who claims victimhood and displaying blind loyalty.

                    Education is a useful tool, you should try it sometime!

                    Reply to this message

              • 31 October 2011 14:00, by Jalaby

                Mr. No Logic,
                Playing around Arab/Africa issue in north Sudan doesn’t work anymore after south separation (thanks), Darfour,South Kordofan and Blue Nile are nothing else than north in terms of culture,tradition,language,habit, religion and belive; and differ from south Sudan on all these facts! no one is saying Sudan is only Arab but both Arab-Africa.

                Reply to this message

                • 31 October 2011 16:29, by Logic

                  Jalaby,

                  Clearly you’ve always been a blind loyalist of the NCP or the Arab/ Islamic identity of North Sudan. Your comment about the uniformity of language, religion and culture among the different areas you’ve mentioned displays your blatant ignorance.

                  I wont even bother attempt educating you, go figure.

                  Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 18:30, by mohammed ali

            Logic,
            The illogical Jalaby in southerners shoes!

            You always reveal your real skin inintentionally!Southerners never talk about sodmization of young people, but you do

            What brings such an issue in a political forum in the first place? Had you had a bad experience? and you are talking out of your complex I just wonder!Because it is always in the back of your mind and you bring it up irreleventy

            Reply to this message

            • 1 November 2011 10:36, by Logic

              Mo Ali, it looks like I’ve touched a nerve! lol

              Why do you and your racist friends always accuse Southern politicians of being alcoholics? Can’t you comment without being offensive, its ironic how you don’t like being offended but its cool for you to offend others.

              A bunch of hypocrites, get a real education about humanity. You scream all day about Palestinian victims but forget about your own.

              Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 09:35, by Jalaby

        Mr. No Logic,
        why are you angry with my comments! why Mr. Kiir sacked out thief Pagan from RoSS cabinet?I’m wondering, were you one of the southern Sudan parliament member before? did you get a job in the south or you still living in the north? rebels have become serious issue in the south, it’s just a matter of time till Mr. Kiir brushed out SPLM-N!

        Reply to this message

        • 31 October 2011 09:43, by Logic

          Abu Dirty Jalabiya

          More than 700 civilians killed since June in both Southern Kurdofan and Blue Nile, the NCP refuses humanitarian aid to civilians in both areas, more than 100,000 displaced to as far as Ethiopia and over a dozen armed groups in Darfur.

          And you have the nerve to talk about Southern rebellion. What is wrong with you people? Do you only know supremacy.

          Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 09:53, by Sam.Eto

            First i wasnt refering to Southerners in my comments. You & not a Southerner and you know who i ment. Second where do you come up with these figures?

            Officially 1500 Southerners killed in South Sudan since independence. God knows really how many !! But im sure your likes and the Americans are covering that up nicely. We know that we own Sudan and will stay - we chose our leaders not Zionists.

            Reply to this message

            • 31 October 2011 11:42, by rock

              To all Northerner and particularly to so called Arabs the issue of Abyei is not laughable matter.and for your information there is no normal south Sudanese was supporting this cowardice idea of pay ransom so that Khartoum can release Abyei it is unacceptable.
              Rock!! man who don`t sell his identity for political gain ah ah!!!!

              Reply to this message

            • 31 October 2011 16:40, by Logic

              Sam.E

              You can try to be a smart ass all you want, but your comment was clear in its direction. There aren’t 12 million Jews in Israel, so you weren’t talking about them and we all know the SPLM declared the southern population to be around 12m.

              Who do you think you can fool? and my comment was directed at Dirty Jalabiya, not you. get it! Fyi, my stats are well sourced.

              I don’t do blind loyalty

              Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 09:59, by Jalaby

            Mr. No Logic,
            Everytime I read your comments I laugh a lot..Thx. Are you Mr. Atem Garang? he was former member of Sudan parliament and SPLM unionist, Mr. Kiir appointed him to serve unrealistic job in the south with no activities and he is doing nothing now!
            Jalaby (Abo Jalabia)

            Reply to this message

            • 31 October 2011 17:15, by Logic

              God help you Abu Dirty Jalabiya, you don’t even make sense!

              Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 11:34, by pabaak

            I don’t buy the ideas of offering ransom of any value to free Abyei from the bondage of NIF regime in Khartoum, in fact I was watching SSTV one time and I came across to media forum, I heard producer asked SPLM member, why always follow the decision of NCP on abyei, once they went to Addis you follow them,also to Kordofan, leaving the Huge base decision on Abyei? I think there were no answers.

            Reply to this message

            • 31 October 2011 11:48, by pabaak

              So I think there no reason to offer many solutions, we should stick to one only and that is the Huge decision on Abyei been belonging to South Sudan, Nobody new to the NCP mentality of dishonoring the agreements, if we hear everyday new proposal from SPLM it make the other folk to feel it will get some consensus of any kind and there is no any alternative other than seeing Abyei in South Sudan map

              Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 09:50, by MMEE

        See the weakness of our government of south-Sudan under the leader ship of Mr. Selfa kiir.
        The government of Mr. Kiir is acting for showing to Abyei people that the government care. but the true is there is no tension for solving Abyei problem and let it’s people live in peace a long side with the rest of southern Sudanese. Even though, there is no tension of protecting Abyei people from the

        Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 09:13, by Abyei Soil

      Abyei has got no price to enable swap take place. How can a country that existed in its nature be offered for swap? I hope in layman language one can understand the location of Abyei geographically and not allocation made by luring people to accept something in either duress influences or misreprsentations. New generation is new, why should people be subjected by wrong people so many times when we

      Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 10:01, by Abyei Soil

        New generation is new, why should people be subjected by wrong people so many times when we know exactly where we belong. Geographically, we are in the South Sudan. What else can I say?

        Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 09:14, by Bush

      @Jalaby

      ... and you, Jalaby AKA slaved-son, are you still alive? the SPLM/A-North did Killed you yet? wait your days are numbered.
      Amum is a hero and anti Jalaba, a person whose value can not be bought by any amount of Arab money. That’s why you hate him much.Most were your pa-pet.

      Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 09:37, by Waucity

      Abyei can not simply belong to the North...The primary owners of Abyei are not northerners...Who does the north have to be difficult when Southern Sudan continue to make it comfortable with its oil revenues?..

      Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 23:58, by Baring

      Dear So Call Jellby

      You can not be a cat and a mice at the sametime. Those Northern Sudanese are Arab Slaves that is it. there is nothing call AfroArab. They refused that deal ok. leave them. they will ask for it in two month from now... Trust me.

      Reply to this message

    • 1 November 2011 12:42, by Jack

      My friend the So called Kiir him self is even dishonest and corrupt, He is suppose to sack him self before Pagan and other Corrupt south Sudanese leaders

      Reply to this message

    • 1 November 2011 12:56, by eye-of-an-eye

      Jalaby,
      I can see you guys are full of sorrows in North, bad luck. Southerners are the most intelegent creatures around this globe, let me tell you somthing, if it was not coz we don’t want to break CPA agreement, you would have seen what had happen to whole remain North at this time, you are the most luckiest. lets just wait for only little time to hear about the whole result for whole Sudan.

      Reply to this message

  • 31 October 2011 09:50, by Apolloos

    Abyei belongs to Nine Dinka Ngok since and forever. Abyei will never and will not be part of north until God change the demography of the this world, but human being cannot.

    Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 09:58, by Sam.Eto

      Abyei never belonged to The Dinka - they moved there after the Nuer chased them out and the British agreed they can move to it. The SPLM sold you these lies for so long you start believing them. It is now part of the North (within the 56 border) by law. Nothing but a referendum can change that!! Good luck - Ha Ha Ha I suggest your Ngok get comfortable where they are with their Dinka brothers.

      Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 12:06, by Arkangelo K.k. Chawul

        The Arabs came to Sudan in 641BC and are now claiming to be citizens but one day time will come to drive you back to where you belong, forget Abyei deep inside South Sudan.how came about that Dinka is a neighbour to Arabs than being Neighbour to Nuba and Darfur? A person who have no place always stick to someone’s place inorder to survive. Abyei belong to South Sudan whether by peace or by force.

        Reply to this message

        • 31 October 2011 12:38, by Sam.Eto

          WRONG - The Dinka came from Kenya - same length, colour, language, worship cows and tribal dances.

          Southerners were never part of the Sudan history until the british added them. The history of Sudan and its people dates to 10000 years ago. They still have their language and culture perserved in the North. The Arab language came in 600A.D - keep your delusional biblical dreams to yourself.

          Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 17:12, by Logic

            These guys are truly racist and pathetic.

            There were more than 7 current day nation states in Africa having the name Sudan in their official territorial documentation, mainly colonies of Europeans.

            The fact they don’t accept Arabs as late comers to Sudan should end the argument. Sam.E, Its height not length, woow, where did they get you from? Don’t answer that...lol!

            Reply to this message

          • 31 October 2011 21:00, by Elijah B. Elkan

            Sam Ito,

            I am sorry dude, but I don’t know what you’re smoking. I will help you in case you don’t know the history. Many people on this forum are confused of your nonsenses comments, please try to convey your point clearly. The Dinka people came from "China" brother!. Do your researcher, before you make a fool of your self.

            Reply to this message

          • 1 November 2011 05:40, by son of abyei

            Sam.Eto

            Haha so you know history now?..what a joke..if anything u need to contact whoever give you that lame plain bullsh*t of a story and try to get this, SUDAN belong to black africans..Abyei is ours nothing about us that relate to you fools

            Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 17:20, by Logic

        "Abyei never belonged to The Dinka" What a funny statement, given that the word Abyei is the name of a tree in the Dinka language.

        I think we all now know the educational level of these racist fools, what a bunch of indoctrinated bigots. You’re the Zionists you so much despise.

        Reply to this message

      • 1 November 2011 04:27, by davidcontrol

        Man you might need to see a doctor, I can’t believe Arabic people just throw big lair that way. besides we southerner have learn more from you guys it is just a matter of time and you who claim Abyei belong to the north, go to school where you learn that Abyei belong to the north.
        addition I really don’t understand why NCP of North always ring the bell of war.

        Reply to this message

  • 31 October 2011 10:10, by Master

    Thats another Joke ! South Sudan/ SPLM wants to buy Abyei from North Sudan - Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha.

    How cheap do you Dinka Ngok feel now ?

    If South Sudan wants it so bad - doesnt that mean there is ALOT of oil in Abyei. But what a stupid offer !! Honestly Pagan who taught you to bargin ? Zionists ? Ha Ha Ha Ha

    Everything for nothing !

    Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 11:45, by Abyei Soil

      How happy are you? And how long will you be happy laughing, laughing over what? You people in the north should learns manners of international relationship. The govt of South Sudan is there forever and whoever changed it then you could be having a possibilities of changing mountain into a sand zone. Therefore, changing Abyei location is as harder as changing dry wood into a young plant. No one can

      Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 11:49, by Abyei Soil

        No one can change our location from South to somewhere else, I said and I mean it.

        Reply to this message

        • 31 October 2011 14:58, by Dinka Dominated SPLA/M

          What are those fake arab of sudan trying to say here? Abyei has no meaning in Arabic language rether than the DINKA names.
          You Godless fake arab can be a terrorise but you can not be A Dinkas or Southreness. we know what you are after and that is why we want to help you but not because we are begging you. whol Sudan is ours and everyone in the world know it. including you fake arab.

          Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 17:27, by Logic

      Another fool named Master but has mastered nothing except how to be brainwashed.

      Northern Sudan Elitists (fake Arabs) are the closest thing to Zionists in Africa, apart from the Afrikaans of South Africa.

      Reply to this message

  • 31 October 2011 14:49, by Cadaai ?o?

    North Sudan needs to leave Abyei alone over their natural given land. NCP, the abduction of Abyei wouldn’t be a good way that will bring in necessarily mutual respect and honesty among two nations in any or another in my view, though. In true sense, Abyei is 100% South Sudan’s land and its people as well.

    Reply to this message

  • 31 October 2011 15:16, by AUGUSTINO DENG

    The problem of Abyei is definitely like a "prostitute girl".

    By Augustino Deng. Jech la mer from Tharpam.

    Reply to this message

    • 31 October 2011 20:16, by twins

      What’s the next step for South Sudanese after North told them to get the hell out with their money and to be taken out of Abyei militarly? Begging for negotiation will get exhausted evetially. Why does splm keep begging for Dinka Nhoks’ land any way. Let the south sit till it has enough power to get its land from Arab then fight because that’s the only way Beshir want it.

      Reply to this message

      • 31 October 2011 21:54, by MJriaksdca

        That is a naive decision by South Sudan government. The Ngok Dinka together with the Abyei Land are Southerners and must be claimed without any appeasing package of incentives. We rather go to war or let the land go because we are coward.

        Reply to this message

Reply to this article


 
 

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.


Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis


Is UNSC only legitimate to Sudan in complaint times? 2012-05-20 01:45:00 By Zechariah Manyok Biar May 19, 2012 — Sudanese leaders seem to think they are smarter than anybody else in this world. They seem to recognize the legitimacy of the United Nations Security (...)

Sudan’s NCP, an obstacle to peaceful co-existence 2012-05-20 01:30:00 By Jacob K. Lupai May 19, 2012 — Peaceful co-existence is what is expected of people the world over in promoting security. Nevertheless, how does peaceful co-existence come about? There are many (...)

On the African Union road map and UN resolution 2046 2012-05-20 01:00:00 By Gamal Adam My 18, 2012 — The African Union’s recent road map which the United Nations Security Council has endorsed with the Resolution 2046 includes a clause that puts pressure on the Sudan (...)


MORE




VIDEOS



Latest Press Releases


Opposition leader under house arrest 2012-05-18 20:40:02 AI - Amnesty International Opposition leader under house arrest 18 May 2012 Ezdehar Jumaa Said Ahmad, a leader of the opposition Sudan People’s Liberation Movement-North, is under house arrest. (...)

AI: SUDANESE JOURNALIST FACES HARASSMENT 2012-05-18 20:27:17 Amnesty International SUDANESE JOURNALIST FACES HARASSMENT 18 May 2012 Faisal Mohammed Salih, a prominent journalist and columnist from Sudan who had been arrested by the National Security (...)

AMNESTY: HEALTH CONCERNS FOR DETAINED ACTIVIST 2012-05-11 20:18:33 Amnesty International Health Concerns For Detained Activist - Bushra Gammar Hussein Rahma 11 May 2012 More than ten months after his arrest, Sudanese activist Bushra Gamar Hussein Rahma (...)


MORE

Copyright © 2003-2012 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.