Home page | News    Friday 5 August 2011

South Sudan parliament’s first sitting fails over internal power wrangling

separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation

August 4, 2011 (KHARTOUM) – The transformed national legislative assembly of the newly born Republic of South Sudan has failed to conduct its first sitting as senior lawmakers wrangle over who to lead the new national house after the integration of MPs coming from Khartoum.

JPEG - 15.6 kb
South Sudan’s President Salva Kiir (2nd L) smiles at the end of Sunday mass in Juba on January 16, 2011, one day after the historical week-long independence referendum vote ended. (Getty)

On Monday President Salva Kiir Mayardit issued a number of presidential decrees transforming the regional South Sudan Legislative Assembly into a national one after independence. He confirmed and merged the membership of the lawmakers elected to both Juba and Khartoum during the interim period by 170 and 96, respectively, and added 66 more new appointees, bringing the total number to 332.

The new house was scheduled to have its first sitting on Wednesday, August 3, in which all the members would take oath of office in the presence of the speaker of the house. However, disagreements over who should lead the new house as speaker or deputy to the current speaker have emerged for the last three days.

The SPLM’s deputy chairman, James Wani Igga, has been serving as the speaker of the house in Juba for the last six years. He was recently deputised by Daniel Awet Akot, who is member of the SPLM’s political bureau, the highest organ of the ruling party and government and former governor of the Lakes state.

Another senior official in the SPLM, Atem Garang, had served for equally six years as deputy speaker in the national legislative assembly in Khartoum.

With the coming back to Juba parliament of the members from Khartoum, the incoming members want to reconcile their ranks with the ranks of members in the previous regional parliament in Juba, hence demanding that the position of either the speaker or the deputy speaker should be allotted to those coming from Khartoum, a demand resisted by Juba based legislators.

A member of the South Sudanese parliament told the Sudan Tribune by telephone from Juba that the two blocks have reached a deadlock in the debate over the issue which he said was referred to President Salva Kiir Mayardit, on Thursday for further intervention.

He added that the difference was also complicated by the accommodation of senior party members as well as consideration of regional balance in the executive and legislative organs of the government.

The MP further said both Igga and Akot wanted to maintain their respective positions as speaker and deputy speaker, respectively, citing article 92 (1&2) of the transitional constitution which did not specify the process of merging the two memberships.

He suggested that there is a need to find a mechanism to organise the merger of the members of the National Assembly of the Republic of Sudan in the South Sudan’s National Legislative Assembly in a way to take in account their ranks and experience.

VICE-PRESIDENT NOT CONSULTED

The Vice President of the Republic of South Sudan, Riek Machar, was not consulted by President Salva Kiir Mayardit in the process leading to the final selection of nominees and appointment of the new members to the national legislative assembly as well as to the council of states, a reliable source has revealed.

A member of parliament who preferred anonymity told the Sudan Tribune that the Vice President was not aware of the final selection process and was as surprised as any body else when the new appointments of 96 members were officially announced on the official South Sudan television.

He further said that the President sidelined his deputy and informally consulted with a number of his close "loyalists" among the current caretaker ministers and advisors, particularly among those that drafted the transitional constitution. He also regretted that the appointed membership is dominated by the Dinka ethnic group.

Attempts by the Sudan Tribune to confirm this development from the office of the Vice President did not succeed.

Machar was constitutionally appointed by Kiir on 10 July for the third time as his deputy following the attainment of independence on 9 July.

The vice-president last June showed his opposition to many provisions of the transitional constitution - including the centralisation of power and the presidents ability to dismiss elected representatives - but Kiir ignored it and even criticised publicly Machar’s position against the presidential attributions.

(ST)

Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 5 August 2011 07:57, by Jayo

    I think the MPs from Khartoum are right.Deputy Speaker Daniel Awet Agot should step aside for Mr Atem Garang who was a deputy in Khartoum Parliament.Mr James Wani deserve to maintain his position as a speaker of the whole house.

    Second, Pres Kiir should have atleast consulted with his deputy Dr Machar especially since this was a very significant appointment of the people’s representatives.I mean the 66 other MPs that Kiir appointed arbitrarily.He should consult next time when he carry out a big decision-making.That is what is called inclusive governance.

    Third,this MP complaining about tribal representation is getting it all wrong.The 96 MPs coming from Khartoum were elected base on constituency representation.The constituencies were allocated based on 2009 census.So,there is no issue of tribal over or under representation there.

    The other 66 MPs that Kiir appointed were appointed with what I think is fair representation.Out of the 66 MPs appointed, only 24 are Dinka which make it 36% of the MPs.I don’t see that as being dominated by Dinka bearing in mind that Dinka are in 7 of 10 states of South Sudan.

    Those opposition MPs should start criticising the government based on policies ,not some minor tribal sensitivities.

    Jayo,thr Nationalist

    Reply to this message

    • 5 August 2011 08:38, by Malou Manyiel

      Jayo,

      Iam of your opinion that called Daniel Awet Akot to step aside and allow Atem Garang to deputies James Wani Igga.
      Mps coming from khartoum have a right.
      However, James Wani has to remain in his position as a speaker of the assembly.

      Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 08:07, by Bush

    I’m seeing there are some MPs in Juba who always wants to collide Kiir and Machar, just simply like that because it’s not the MPs to talk on behave of the vice president that he was not informed by the president.

    I think the President doesn’t need to consult his vice everyday in every steps he takes.

    Reply to this message

    • 5 August 2011 11:33, by dakin

      Bush

      yor critic thiking is low low low. Are u katorian realy. Oh dear what did yor mother fed you on? Cokroches. I am damn sic of such idiot pretender.

      When they mobile rape and loot yor parents while fearing jalaba in juba and yo cal liberation i can’t agre you.

      What a one man land grader katoria of mobor moto who live in kator! God bles the him

      shame shame shame migit. If I wer yor father i woul had sold you to buy a dog

      Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 08:13, by Just Junubi

    I wonder what were the intentions of this anonymous member of parliament when he stated that " he regretted that the appointed membership is dominated by the Dinka ethnic group"

    Yes, He does have every right to regret it but when looking at facts, Dinka’s are inhabitant to 7 out the 10 States of south Sudan so in representing their constituencies in parliament, they will always out number the rest of our beloved tribes.
    Those in influential positions should look at facts and be logical in expressing their thoughts.

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 08:18, by Just Junubi

    Jayo

    I see you beat me to it, I was in the process of typing and posting. Anyways, I agree with you 100%.

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 08:34, by Nan dit

    This is not a simple task,think wisely who will lead the house in the new nation.

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 08:55, by Malual Dungdit

    Creation of another institutionalized position for the 2nd Deputy Speaker for Garang

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 09:03, by Alier42

    Lack of experience is to blame for internal power wrangling in our national assembly.our mps should know what we expect from them,we are in a new nation/country,the national assembly will have alot of obligations to do to transform the new born nation to meet national and international standard and to give quality services to it citizens.they should know what their special obligations are,other than who should be who in the national assessbly,it time for our mps to put every thing right in the country.what they want to do is to demage our national image as a nation and the pride we are entitled to as a country.

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 09:49, by Alfredo christiani

    Dear readers
    To avoid confusion in our new born country. The following appointments are to take place
    1- James wani igga to be appointed as a second vice president of the republic of south Sudan
    2- Atem Garang to be appointed as a speaker of national legislative assembly for ROSS
    3- Daniel awet to remained deputy speaker in the assembly
    Atem Garang has done a lot in Khartoum so he deserved to be speaker of national assembly of Ross
    Secondly appointment should base on qualifications not by tribes or states, that all

    Reply to this message

    • 5 August 2011 16:11, by Nhomlawda

      Alfredo

      I support your suggested solution on this issue.

      Mr. President should appoint Hon. James Wani Igga as second VP within this transitional period and Atem Garang should take over James Wani position in parliamnet.

      Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 12:53, by PPT The Great

    This is very crucial stage where by government of south Sudan must take care of. those people who have been holding high position need to be convince kindly such that the government can run it program smoothly. there are no enough space in government to accommodate all skillful person. therefor President need to consult his vice president to communicate with those new appointees to accept whatever position given to them.
    It is very bad image to fight for higher position for the first time.

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 13:43, by Josh

    Uganda and kenya are just ready to support equatorians against the naket tribes. wow taking refuges to khortoum would be as another challenge. If nuer, shiruk, equatoria stands to fuck the world Oop where would the naket animals go? The only door my bitch sexy friends can scape through is Khortoum. I feel honnnnnney for ya boy. I love u black big ass.

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 14:09, by Josh

    You have to look at the history of the Middle East in particular. It has been one of failure and frustration, of feudalism and tribalism

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 15:48, by Wundit

    good decision made by mr president is ok, who is Riak machar to be consulted? when did it happen for man to consult woman? this guy calling himself vice president is a truth worthy nuer he can not deserve to be consulted

    Reply to this message

    • 5 August 2011 17:25, by Space

      Dictatorship system
      I think the constitution has establish a one man system where president control the House, the cabinets and Army to fire and appoint at will. This is not healthy for our Country.

      That’s why Govt is taking long to be formed; one month down the road. So what is the essence of Independent? people need services. If president doesn’t involve the Army Council and Council of Vetrans, then he will have difficulty forming the Govt. tell them not to copy games from neighbouring countries. South Sudanese are different people and your tricks will not work there. Whether you like it or not, the right of people shall prevail over selfish interest.

      Wani and Awet are great Heroes but less competence in speakership position. We need them as Ministers. We need vibrant speakers who will check the Govt. People must work. Is not looting any more where a minister earn lot of money and then again give their wives, sons and daughters contracts to take huge money home without doing anything. They don’t even feel a shame of doing that. They do things as if they will not come back next time and surely they will not.

      Reply to this message

      • 6 August 2011 02:02, by M’ alual

        Mr. SPACE, your points are what the government, that is yet to be formed, if possible, should be thinking to execute out for the public good. But remebmer that the coming speaker with his coming deputy for the new parliament will be non-partisan to the major ruling party- the SPLM, including the opposition political parties. In other wards, both speakers will not opinion to disagree or agree with the government position, but remained neutral at all times. They will not criticise the government position, but maintain orderliness in the parliament, in case if parliamentarians are wrangling or quarrelling over the motions or bills in the house. Speakers of parliament are just there to vote on the parliamentary motions and bills, when there is a tie in the parliament. Therefore, they will never shake anything up in the next parliament, because they will be non-partisans for every parliamentary session. The only political body, who can be operating with complete independence to shake thing up in the coming parliament, for example, questioning any contempt or excessive corruptions or money laundary or embezzlement by political cronies or systematic looting by the ruling party, is a vibrant and powerful opposition political party. Finally, speakers are not government in waiting, so they don’t care about ethics on the government. But opposition political parties are government in waiting, therefore they care and demand toughest accountability and responsibility on a government, operating without moral and ethical standards. Having said, I have no idea whether political anaylsts and pundits have educated the public enough about the role of a speaker of parliament throught mass media. I just have impression that the public seemed to be impressed and reccommending the former speaker of the Government of National Unity, Atem Garang,and the fomer speaker of the Semi-Autonomous Government of South Sudan, Wani Igga, but in those parliaments then, both Atem and Wani were politically partisans to the SPLM party for the obivious reason. Just because you are a speaker will not mean that you will be speaking the language of an opposition political party but instead you will be sitting in the front chair for every parliamentary debates, bascially saying these phrases order, order please, order, order please-that’s it and it doesn’t mean anything, as far as government integrity and honesty is concerned.

        Reply to this message

    • 10 August 2011 01:55, by Ke kon cowkun

      People don’t surprise for any such a useless comment that came from useless people.If we go a long to our History,we are all South Sudanese,no differentiation a among us.Let me encourage our women Jang or Dinka.Dinka or jang don’t really know how to rule people and will never know,b/c they are not a human being how can an animals rule human being? that’s why you can see a lot of corruption in the Government.When I come to the point that Dr.Riek Machar or Nuer are women,it is some thing make me laughing,hahah hahah,.Because how can Nuer be women?Dinka knew us very well,how we fucking them and the rest of the world knew very well.We are the real human being.We are and always will be your leaders,shield and bucklers.

      Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 17:57, by Thonkiir

    Dear all,
    If we want our country to be peaceful and fair without doubt let Kiir step down and Dr.Riek Machar, would go up you will see the big changes Kiir too shallow enough and rely on other people brains always why don’t growing up! You know dear Dinkas followers this guy has block our chances. He sold all positions to other minority tribes to maintain him in power for so long unless Dinkas who make themselves cheap and sleeping at Kiir doors are the ones who get advantage now plus his Gokrial men who always looting money day and night what kind of Dinkas are these?

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 18:13, by Thonkiir

    We missed our beloved leader Dr.John Garang. Garang wasn’t known as a surrounding himself with all corrupts people from Twic but selecting capable people from all the minority and majority tribes that why we been achieving CPA. All those years misspending are Garang was been sett by Garang de Mabior, now you would the dictator government he trying to exclude others

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 18:18, by Dani

    My God wrangling does not mean that those who interested in those positions want to serve people but for there interests everyone want to get rich by misusing public funds. God will do away with you if you are not going to be sincere to serve public interest. My worry is if Kiir and Riek do not cooperate then the govt will ever be like that and let me assure you that if you exposed all your internal problems (conflicts/corruption) then the int’l community will not fulfill their promises to the people of S.Sudan. Hoo My God help your people before they help themselves.
    Dani, K’la

    Reply to this message

  • 5 August 2011 18:30, by Thonkiir

    Bravo Mr.space I am always like way you are talking man whether or not this guy will see himself underdog soon maybe thinking four years are enough after that he still not satifying and continuning with his leadership greedyness but we will put on his gum if he want

    Reply to this message

  • 6 August 2011 05:33, by Monydu

    I think Mr. Mayardit did bad job for not consulting Mr .Machar. he is his vice and it doesn’t make sense if you appoint somebody as your vice and try to hide government decision from him.

    Secondly to the wicked who complians about Dinka. I would like to ask him a question. " what wuold you do if you kills your antelope and your friend just help you only by looking at you". how much of the meat would you later give to your friend? probably not much. that should have happened gov’t but to keep everybody united, Dinka’s have not really taken that priciple but instead they have included anybody who have qualified to served. let not be driven away by so called independence. it’s our land and we know the history. let look at leader’s works but not to judge them according to their tribes. we will not developed this country if we could judge or vote for people according to their tribes.

    We are South Sudanese and our main challenge would be development of this country. please everybody have love for this young nation and resist from tribalism and corruption.

    Finally i would like to see Atem Garang as deputy speaker of the house.
    Many thanks my dear brothers and sisters for your comments.

    Akeliokdit monydu.

    Reply to this message

  • 6 August 2011 18:49, by Kour Taban

    Do we want South Sudan to end before it starts over some empty and greedy power struggle?
    Our leaders should demonstrate patriotism by confirming our great patriot RH Wani Egga as the Speaker. For a model of a three figures Leadership of Wani, Machar and Salva Kiir is what can carry South Sudan to the shore of safety and unity.
    No one is interested in power struggle at this stage specially the majority of our people in the rural South Sudan and the refugee communities across the Globe. All what is needed is a South Sudan that can start now – not tomorrow- to tackle the needs of it suffering people, who are waiting patiently for proper roads, schools for their children and hospitals, especially as their sons and daughters are finally in charge.
    In our own South Sudan Parliament – the 1st parliament of an Independent South Sudan, consensus not power wrangling should be the norm, so that we can launch our National Parliament and government, as a mark of our political maturity- worthy of statehood- in our beloved and sovereign South Sudan

    Ps: Out National Anthem states: "------uphold us United in peace and harmony ---------" Shame on you, so called Honourable MPs: stop wrangling and Unite to confirm Wani Ega who proclaimed the Independent of our Great Nations. Long live South Sudan. On that Juba Sunny day , we all wept as we remember our sisters, brothers uncles and fathers who couldn’t make to the 9th July.

    Reply to this message

Reply to this article


 
 

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.


Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis


Is UNSC only legitimate to Sudan in complaint times? 2012-05-20 01:45:00 By Zechariah Manyok Biar May 19, 2012 — Sudanese leaders seem to think they are smarter than anybody else in this world. They seem to recognize the legitimacy of the United Nations Security (...)

Sudan’s NCP, an obstacle to peaceful co-existence 2012-05-20 01:30:00 By Jacob K. Lupai May 19, 2012 — Peaceful co-existence is what is expected of people the world over in promoting security. Nevertheless, how does peaceful co-existence come about? There are many (...)

On the African Union road map and UN resolution 2046 2012-05-20 01:00:00 By Gamal Adam My 18, 2012 — The African Union’s recent road map which the United Nations Security Council has endorsed with the Resolution 2046 includes a clause that puts pressure on the Sudan (...)


MORE




VIDEOS



Latest Press Releases


Opposition leader under house arrest 2012-05-18 20:40:02 AI - Amnesty International Opposition leader under house arrest 18 May 2012 Ezdehar Jumaa Said Ahmad, a leader of the opposition Sudan People’s Liberation Movement-North, is under house arrest. (...)

AI: SUDANESE JOURNALIST FACES HARASSMENT 2012-05-18 20:27:17 Amnesty International SUDANESE JOURNALIST FACES HARASSMENT 18 May 2012 Faisal Mohammed Salih, a prominent journalist and columnist from Sudan who had been arrested by the National Security (...)

AMNESTY: HEALTH CONCERNS FOR DETAINED ACTIVIST 2012-05-11 20:18:33 Amnesty International Health Concerns For Detained Activist - Bushra Gammar Hussein Rahma 11 May 2012 More than ten months after his arrest, Sudanese activist Bushra Gamar Hussein Rahma (...)


MORE

Copyright © 2003-2012 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.