Home | Comment & Analysis    Tuesday 17 January 2012

Garang Death: a need for fresh probe

separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation

By Isaiah Abraham

January 17, 2012 — The circumstances which led to the untimely death of the South Sudanese leader Dr. John Garang de Mabior in a tragic helicopter crash will never be fully known. Dr. Garang was returning to Sudan after a brief visit to Uganda where he met president Yoweri Museveni when the helicopter disappeared in the mountain ranges of South Sudan on 30th July 2005, while returning to his base at Kamotho (New Site) in Eastern Equatoria Region.The Ugandan President hosted late Garang and four other dignitaries in his rural area of Rwakitura in Mabarara District..

The then Government of the Sudan rushed to form an Investigation Committee to look into exact causes of the crash, and the official finding point to human error on the side of the pilot. That is to say that the helicopter came down due to bad weather. But speculations persist even after the official pronouncement that point to an opposite direction, that there could be someone or groups who were on the sabotage.

Who killed Garang?

For instance there have been speculations that Khartoum was much involved in Garang disappearance because to them the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) could be easily crippled once Garang is out of the picture. People then talked of big shots (NIF politicians) shuttling between Kampala and Khartoum before, during and after the tragedy on the same mission.

Other speculations were that perhaps there could be involvement of some Southern Sudanese politicians in the plot since at a time there was a political scene- rivalry within the SPLA that was squarely suppressed or handled by Rev. Canon Clement Janda . In the SPLA, by the way, we were never taught anything terrorism or anything similar to that school. So it was impossible to give a damp ear to this wild speculation. Our leaders differed, locked themsleves up, but not to an extreme thinking (assassination).

The other speculation still points a finger to the Lord Resistance Army (LRA) elements within the Ugandan Defense Force. Yet there is another group that thought that the work could be that of the CIA of the United States because of the Garang overbearing political stardom. But also there is another group that never spared the current Ugandan President.

But that isn’t a point to go after who actually killed Garang. The issue here however is the relationship between facts surrounding his death. Once things becomes clear the next thing is who did it and why.

There may have been powerful influential forces vying for influence in the oil rich country of Sudan, and that was a living fact, could they be one behind the assassination? I don’t know and no way to pin a blame when there is no substantive evidence proving anything in white and black. Sometime I feel like leaving everything in the hand of the Creator, and just pray for the soul of our great man and founding father of our nation Gen. Dr. John Garang de Mabior, but that does help me either. Despite pieces here and there the truth will never be late!

That is what am seeking for. Once thing go terribly wrong as was the case during the Interim Period under amateurish leader called Kiir, I ran to curse the invisible hands behind the disappearance of the big father and a leader. Garang was more than ready for any challenge; that is a living truth about him. His lost is irreparable!

Just to repeat myself as came above: while there exists speculations tied to the vested interested of certain governments and groups to silence Garang the reality is that no evidence has been reported to the outside world that would substantiate any claim of foul play, but am suspicious only because of the unusual episodes surrounding the matter at hand.

Causes of the crash not convincing

My suspicion stems from the following cases- am not going to prolong any discussion on each case anyway. Now let us get started: there is this fateful helicopter named as MY 72; there are contradictions about its worth or worth not. The chopper was reported to be in a “good health” according to the then Russian Director for Interstate Aviation Committee, Mr. Rudolf Temurazov, the very person that overhauled it. This dispels an earlier circulation that the chopper was blindly flying at night or that it was a junk chopper.

Rudolf sentiment was echoed by non other the Ugandan President Yoweri Kaguta Museveni in Yei South Sudan during one of the mourning occasions. His part of the statement reads thus:

“… the chopper was overhauled executive and has some instruments upgrade before the crash. .. the helicopter was equipped with ability to show the pilot the altitude using both radio altimeter that shows how far are you from the ground as well as a barometer altimeter that shows you how high are you from sea level; a weather radar that shows you bad clouds ahead as well as mountain ranges up to 100 KMS away, Advanced Moving Map System (A MMS) that shows you where you are at any particular time and the terrain features such as mountains; a powerful flood light system to avoid hitting trees and other landing site obstacles; an audio warning in case you are approaching a mountain ahead”.

If you take each piece and then put everything together you will find that there was no question about the helicopter defect or malfunctioning of the engine. The chopper was in good health. The question then is how did the crash occur on this state of the art kind of a machine that ‘sees’ and detect danger before it actually occurred. If this chopper had radar that could ‘show mountain up to 100 kilometers away’, how did this particular accident happen? If the helicopter was in good condition, then there must an external factor because the bad weather thing doesn’t matter much in the report. This is where we are coming and no one knows that factor yet.

The second suspicious is about the loud silence related to the purported meeting between President Museveni and Garang. It appeared that there was a special meeting for the Ugandan President with five important foreigners (3 Europeans, an American and Garang), and no single media was invited, why? How about the identity of the Europeans and the American? Is anyone aware of their profile and the topic of their discussion with the two African leaders (Museveni and Garang).

The third one is about the wreckage of the chopper; whether or why charred when the bodies were identifiable and not much signs of burns were visible. In another word, the chopper either caught fire before it crashes otherwise if it was after the crash, the bodies of the victim could have all charred. This brings another theory that perhaps an explosion happened within the machine without affecting the passengers. Who then had planted the explosive?

The forth suspicion that the crash wasn’t normal is that there was no single photograph of the crash that was published, or released despite immense coverage by credible international media houses. Garang disappearance was covered widely by Atlanta base Cable News Network (CNN), the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), both for radio and the television, Radio France International, the Voice of America, the South African Broadcasting Corporation and all the major wire news services: the Associated Press and United Press International of the United States, Agency France Presse (AFP) of France, Reuters of United Kingdom (Britain) and Xinhua of China yet no reports published or any sketch of the helicopter on its wrecked state during the first few days of the incidence. The question is why?

Fifth, why did the Ugandan government block fresh investigation by an American Insurance Company associated with late Garang. Recall, the company before attempting to compensate requested in vain to find causes of the crash. This company could have hired independent minded team that could have helped allay fears that indeed there were no invisible hands that went for an assassination target. Was the Ugandan government part of the conspiracy to eliminate Garang? I don’t know, time will tell.

Sixth, the black boxes for the helicopter were recovered but content weren’t made public why? The Flight Data Recorder (FDR) popularly known as ‘black box’ preserves the records of what happened in an event of a crash. The box is made of nearly indestructible materials that even if the plane is destroyed the box can be found and retrieved. This is done to help during the investigation because the box contains recording of the status of the plane, measurement of altitude, air pressure as well as mechanical status among others.

In our case then the box was said to have been taken to Russia and there you find inconsistencies about what was recorded. If bodies were found and almost anything else, how could anyone suggest that black boxes of that chopper were destroyed or that they don’t give enough details of what transpired there during the crash. There is something that is unclear and hence a suspicion!

Seven, if the turbulent weather was the cause of the crash, why didn’t Colonel Peter Nyakairu (the captain of the helicopter) press for a distress call to Entebbe Control Center for possible courses of action. This suggests that all the aircraft’s parameters were performing normally until impact. Therefore Entebbe was not telling the truth and something terrible happened someone doesn’t want us to know it.

Eight, we are told that according to Control Aviation Authority (CAA) there, no plane including of course helicopters is allowed from Entebbe to leave after 5 PM for a period more than one hour, how did the authorities float this rule? Perhaps someone prevailed up on the Aviation to twist the rule, but intellect has it that Garang wasn’t an easy man to put his life and that of his men at risk. He couldn’t have guided a serious guerrilla liberation war against powerful Khartoum, if he was a pliable as others would want us to believe him differently in death. He was assured of the reliability of the plane, and was confidence that he will reach. The helicopter factor comes in again and that is why the element theory never leaves our minds.

Ninth, we have had an abnormal crack down of anything associated with opening up of another investigation on matters surrounding Garang death. A case in point is that of Hon. Aleu Ayieny Aleu, a veteran SPLA man who fought selflessly for his country and people was uncharacteristically kicked out of the National Cabinet and was threaten of eviction from the SPLM if he doesn’t stop prodding on Garang death circumstances. This came about after he openly questioned the so-called official position that the plane came down because of human error due to bad weather.

Re-call Mr. Aleu was one of the members of the Investigation Committee sent to the scene of the crash. He accompanied the black box down to Russia and he returned suspicious like this little author. He didn’t access anything or made to know what was actually there in the FDR. Now brethren, by just expressing a doubt on an anomaly does that require a punishment? Was Garang a burden to SPLM leaders and by him gone, everything would just be fine? This brings to mind that perhaps there could be people around here who are trying to protect their skin and if yes then we must be afraid!

Then there is this query (ten): the actual identification number for the chopper was in contradiction. One time the report says the MY 72 chopper that killed Garang was carrying registration number 605 and the other from the presidential rotor burp is 8-1930-0008221-5387; so which is which? Why provided different numbers on the same chopper. It seemed though that the true helicopter in question could be different from what was actually in use for the Ugandan President. Did Entebbe give Capt. Peter helicopter that is detonated? If yes who did it.

Needless to mention why was the statement on the exact feet of the helicopter different; the experts talked of 7000 while the exact flying feet was recorded at 500.4 feet, the true distance between the plane and the earth.

In short I don’t care whether Garang was a villain to you, but for the sake of the truth, and given the stature of that man, someone will have to clear the air about the grey areas mentioned above. Garang can’t just die like that and the entire nation, especially his colleagues keep on burying their heads in the denial. By knowing the truth, the nation will start with a clear conscience that nothing was awry but natural like any other tragedy. To die is inevitable but to go under cloudy grounds is a snarl of reality about death itself .

South National Parliament over to you; you have started these days very well on accountability (read Wondu Auditing Report).

Isaiah Abraham lives in Juba; he’s on Isaiah_abraham@yahoo.co.uk



The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it to comment@sudantribune.com

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication. Please include your full name, relevant personal information and political affiliations.
Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.

- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments

Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.

There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your comment as an article to comment@sudantribune.com

Kind regards,

The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
  • 17 January 2012 07:05, by George Bol

    Mr Abraham, I am doubting like you brother. The SPLM want to avoid explosion during the CPA,but they know what happened to our visionary leader-Dr John Garang de Mabior.Perhaps we know what happened to Rwanda and Burundi presidents, Laura Kabila, George Athor, and many others.Why changing planes? why everybody die in the routes of Uganda? The president of Uganda has big hands with Khartoum.

    repondre message

    • 17 January 2012 09:17, by Ruach

      He is now the president of United Sudan in the hell.He die with his visions of Uniting Sudan.Of course he was a "hero",but the vision that led him to hell was useless.Hell to visionless people who still believed in him! I didn’t trust him

      repondre message

      • 17 January 2012 13:10, by Dinka Dominated SPLA/M

        Non of your nuer nyagateen leaders will reach the due respect and well design leadership of Mr Dr John Garang,
        Garang was so smart that is why he signed CPA which could not be done by your nassir gangsters.
        Death to nuern nyagateen.

        repondre message

    • 18 January 2012 14:37, by John Bang

      Gone case is gone,there is no way of talking about the dead man.He brought us to CPA if we fail to manage ourselves who do we blame? The way you mentioned about their death was not because of going to Uganda,that was God plan that all of them will die there.

      repondre message

  • 17 January 2012 10:24, by Lokorai

    Brothe Ruach,

    Have respect; bad manners can’t add up when serious matters are in discussion.

    Wait, some of you will always fault against De Mabior because of Dr. Riek Machar.

    Death to Dinka and Nuer, animals!

    Lokorai

    repondre message

    • 18 January 2012 10:13, by John Bang

      Shame on you Lokorai(Nyamnyam) you keep hanging up there untill you become to realise that these are your great powers and great leadership,keep calling them animals till you get tire of it.Hell with your words.

      repondre message

  • 17 January 2012 17:42, by Kim Deng

    Garang’s disciples,

    Because of Nasir move, Garang divorced and abandoned the alliance, called SPLA/M 1st National Convent at Chukudum in 1994 and the self-determination for South Sudan was the first agenda in that Convention. The movement changed from its former name SPLA/M as it was well-known back then to SPLM/A. Garang put self-determination for South Sudan to be the first agenda/priority..

    repondre message

  • 17 January 2012 17:43, by Kim Deng

    in that Convention. The movement changed from its former name SPLA/M as it was well-known back then to SPLM/A. Garang put self-determination for South Sudan to be the first agenda/priority whenever there is a peace talks with Khartoum government and Garang himself eventually signed for it, the self-determination for people of Southern Sudan in CPA. Garang gave up his “New Sudan,” vision, a vision

    repondre message

  • 17 January 2012 17:44, by Kim Deng

    he always refers as a “vision of no-return.” This raised too many unsettling questions from his allies especially the inner circle of NDA, Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile who were oblivious and betrayed at the same time by his self-observed “New Sudan,” vision until they realized that Garang shamelessly made a U-turn which left them in illusion.

    repondre message

  • 17 January 2012 20:18, by Elijah B. Elkan

    Mr Abraham, Your article bring up many of the good points no one dare to bring up. Dr. DeMabior was assassinated and that a fact.You have mentioned few groups but there are some groups you are not aware of. This is going to surprise you and some people on this discussion board. The conspirators are closer to home than you think.

    repondre message

    • 17 January 2012 23:21, by akid malual

      Be aware and attempt to this read careful, which i sometime speak and issue to you the sense acknowledge in benefit you and our new born Nation. the lost of our leader John Garang, is a great mess to our direction of country. in my view that i definitely speak in mind of the goodwill. am a noun to you that. to make our country become grateful.make John Garang happy even is not longer but his legac

      repondre message

      • 18 January 2012 20:12, by LL Reuben

        Ruach,

        Garang is not in hell, he is in paradise. However, he is not happy about the crisis his nation is in right now. That’s all I can say to you, son my uncle. An abusive language toward this man (deMabior) is absolutely intolerable, otherwise I wish your community good lucks in thier endeveour, what every it might be.

        repondre message

  • 18 January 2012 04:10, by Sundayw

    Very interesting theories. However, knowing what really happened to Dr. Garang is as dangerous as anything to regional security. Dr. Garang is dead and is in Heaven. Let’s leave it at that. It would not serve South’s interest to know issues surrounding his demise. By the way, the European diplomats and American ambassador were present at that meeting in Museveni’s house.

    repondre message

    • 18 January 2012 20:11, by Elijah B. Elkan

      Mr. Sundayw, Don’t be naive, there is no time limit in case murder and assassination. There is no such thing as to leave it alone. For your information sir, this is not a "theory" but fact. Dr. John DeMabior was assassinated. Khartoum and Uganda president has dirty hands. As much as I despise George Athor, he visited with Uganda president and windup dead. Think twice about giving up easily.

      repondre message

      • 19 January 2012 02:55, by Sundayw

        Did I recall right that you’re in charge of 130 employees? I seriously doubt that. Rely on facts and not a bunch of conspiracy theories that do not mirror known facts. Anyway, we all loved Dr. Garang. He lived, served, and met untimely demise. That is tragic. However, this is a simple accidents. Don’t turn it into something more than that.

        repondre message

  • 18 January 2012 06:55, by Sobat

    I have been telling friends and colleagues that the first suspect and person behind the death of Garang is Museveni period. Instead, for these stupid Nuer, Dinka and useless community called Equatorians wasting their energy insulting themselves on this forum, why build our South Sudan Army, march to Kampala kill Museveni and close this chapter.

    repondre message

    • 18 January 2012 09:55, by akid malual

      Following the liberation of Torit in 1991 he sent for the late Cdr Paul Ali Gattali, to visit the liberated town. Ali Gattala, you may recall, as a Lt in the Equtoria Corps, was involved in the August 1955 Torit Uprising, and afterwards distinguished himself as an effective guerrilla commander in the subsequent Anya Nya I Movement. However, in 1972 he anticipated the weaknesses in the Addis Ababa

      repondre message

      • 18 January 2012 20:41, by Elijah B. Elkan

        Mr. Malual,Regarding your comment(s) what this comment of yours have to do with Mr. Abraham article. Fact, Many Equtorians are more Ugandans/Kenyans than they are south Sudanese. Did any of you know there was a meeting between Equtorians Intellectual with Uganda president in 2003?. These intellectuals are from Europe, Canada, and United States. Would you like to know their agenda?. Stay tune!.

        repondre message

        • 26 January 2012 13:36, by Burennye Boya

          Elijah,
          You are very stupid.How can yo say many equatorians are more ugandans/Kenyans than SOuth Sudanese? Why not say some tribes in Upper Nile bordering Ethipia are more Etiopians ?Why not say some tribes in WBG bordering Central Africa are more Central Africans? Yes there are bad and good people in Equatoria but do not generalize at all. Be an intellectual please.

          repondre message

  • 19 January 2012 09:02, by lope lomohidang

    Isaiah your alright but in one of the martyrs day madam de mabior
    pronounced clearly that her husband did not die in a plane crash but he was assassinated she knows the final destination of garang death

    repondre message

  • 6 May 2013 22:39, by dennishobson

    R0V1LQBQug564ORzgM1F5BKKBTHCcQssanyong actyon madeira plastica plastic lumber Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little somethin

    repondre message

Comment on this article


 
 

The following ads are provided by Google. SudanTribune has no authority on it.


Sudan Tribune

Promote your Page too

Latest Comments & Analysis


Sudan’s Civil Disobedience: Africa’s latest "Hashtag Revolution"? 2016-11-30 06:14:21 by Suliman Baldo November 29, 2016 “Because of the nature of the dictatorship we are under, you are forced to embrace the use of social media, . . . It’s not secure to try and use the tactics (...)

IGAD : why not a South Sudanese head? 2016-11-29 05:38:32 By Amb. Dhano Obongo Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD), in Eastern Africa Community was formed in1996 succeed the Intergovernmental Authority on Drought and Development (IGADD) (...)

SLM Al-Nur to U.S. Booth: ’Negotiations by Khartoum are illusory’ 2016-11-28 15:46:50 ATTN: U.S. Special Envoy for Sudan and South Sudan; Ambassador Donald Booth by Abdul Wahid al-Nur Sir, Your calumnious editorial scapegoating me as the primary obstacle to peace in Darfur is so (...)


MORE






Latest Press Releases


Amnesty urges to investigate chemical weapons Sudan’s Jebel Marra 2016-10-12 12:52:01 Sudan: International chemical weapons investigation urgently needed into horrific Jebel Marra attacksAMNESTY INTERNATIONAL NEWSFLASH 11 October 2016 Sudan: International chemical weapons (...)

UNAMID JSR’s statement read to the media on peace in Darfur 2016-10-10 20:57:56 African Union United Nations Mission in Darfur Though the region of Darfur is relatively peaceful at this time, a small portion of Jebel Marra within Darfur continues to be intermittently (...)

Sudan: No justice for protester killings 2016-09-23 08:03:30 (Nairobi, September 22, 2016) – Sudanese authorities have yet to provide justice to victims of a violent crackdown on anti-austerity protesters in Khartoum in September 2013, the African Centre (...)


MORE

Copyright © 2003-2016 SudanTribune - All rights reserved.